Department of Psychiatry, University of Maryland Medical Center, Baltimore, MD, United States; University of Maryland/Sheppard Pratt Psychiatry Residency Program, Baltimore, MD, USA.
J Affect Disord. 2020 Feb 1;262:155-164. doi: 10.1016/j.jad.2019.11.014. Epub 2019 Nov 4.
Various associations between monthly Google search volumes (MGSVs) and monthly suicide rates (MSRs) have been reported. However, these studies often analyzed a limited number of search terms using suboptimal statistical methods. While controlling for spurious associations, this study examined a wide array of suicide-related search terms to elucidate if their MGSVs correlated with future MSRs.
MGSVs of 111 candidate suicide-related terms were calculated by averaging 10 time-series data per term obtained from Google Trends. Box-Jenkins transfer function modeling was applied to time-series data of MGSV and MSR among the total, male, and female populations of the United States between 2004 and 2017. Cross-correlation coefficients between MGSVs and MSRs were calculated at lags -3, -2, and -1. Sensitivity analysis identified cross-correlations whose direction and significance (p<0.05) persisted in two other time spans: 126 and 84 months.
Eighty-nine terms were analyzed. MGSVs of 31 terms significantly correlated with MSRs in the total, male, or female population. In the sensitivity analysis, three terms stably exhibited significant positive correlation: "generalized anxiety disorder" (total; lag -3), "anxiety disorder" (total and male; lag -3), and "laid off" (total, male, and female; lag -2). The term sleep problem (total and female; lag -1) consistently showed significant negative correlations.
Sex- or age-specific search-volume data, lags of less than a month, and potential confounding factors of MGSV and MSR were not explored.
trends in MGSV of four terms tend to precede changes in MSR. These terms may enable more accurate forecasting of future suicides.
已有研究报告了月度谷歌搜索量(MGSV)与月度自杀率(MSR)之间的各种关联。然而,这些研究通常使用次优的统计方法分析数量有限的搜索词。本研究在控制虚假关联的情况下,使用广泛的与自杀相关的搜索词来探究其 MGSV 是否与未来的 MSR 相关。
通过对 2004 年至 2017 年间美国总人口、男性和女性的每个术语的 10 个时间序列数据进行平均,计算了 111 个候选自杀相关术语的 MGSV。Box-Jenkins 传递函数模型被应用于 MGSV 和 MSR 的时间序列数据。计算了 MGSV 和 MSR 之间在 -3、-2 和-1 滞后的交叉相关系数。在另外两个时间跨度(126 个月和 84 个月)中,对方向和意义(p<0.05)持续的交叉相关进行了敏感性分析。
分析了 89 个术语。31 个术语的 MGSV 与总人口、男性或女性人口的 MSR 显著相关。在敏感性分析中,有三个术语稳定地表现出显著的正相关:“广泛性焦虑障碍”(总人口;滞后 -3)、“焦虑障碍”(总人口和男性;滞后 -3)和“下岗”(总人口、男性和女性;滞后 -2)。术语“睡眠问题”(总人口和女性;滞后 -1)始终表现出显著的负相关。
未探讨性别或年龄特异性搜索量数据、滞后少于一个月以及 MGSV 和 MSR 的潜在混杂因素。
四个术语的 MGSV 趋势往往先于 MSR 的变化。这些术语可能使未来自杀的预测更加准确。