McMichael Brianna, Nickel Amanda, Duffy Elizabeth A, Skjefte Lisa, Lee Lor, Park Patina, Nelson Stephen C, Puumala Susan, Kharbanda Anupam B
Children's Minnesota Research Institute, Children's Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA.
Department of Advocacy and Child Health Policy, Children's Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA.
J Patient Exp. 2019 Dec;6(4):257-264. doi: 10.1177/2374373518798111. Epub 2018 Sep 9.
American Indian (AI) children experience significant disparities in health-care access. As a result, they are more likely to use the emergency department (ED) for nonemergent visits than white children. In a recent study, pediatric ED providers have shown an implicit bias for white children over AI children. To combat implicit bias in an ED setting, we created a protocol for training ED providers as health equity coaches.
The intervention took place during the fall of 2016 and was composed of 4 educational lectures, 6 to 8 hours of service learning in AI communities, and the participant's dissemination of what was learned through formal presentations and informal conversations with other ED staff. We measured the impact of this intervention on the intervention participants with a group interview at the completion of the intervention.
The findings from the group interview provide feedback on what was learned during the intervention, how it impacted providers, and feedback on the structure of the intervention. Overall ED providers reported the intervention improved awareness of their implicit bias and ways to improve communication and care for AI patients. Additional institutional policy and procedural changes are necessary to effectively and sustainably address health disparities affecting AI populations.
The participating providers identified their lack of knowledge regarding AI cultures at the start of the intervention and it became clear that their knowledge, comfort, and relationships with AI communities increased as a result of this intervention.
美国印第安(AI)儿童在医疗保健可及性方面存在显著差异。因此,与白人儿童相比,他们更有可能因非紧急就诊而使用急诊科(ED)。在最近的一项研究中,儿科急诊科医护人员对白人儿童表现出比对AI儿童的隐性偏见。为了在急诊科环境中对抗隐性偏见,我们制定了一项将急诊科医护人员培训为健康公平教练的方案。
干预在2016年秋季进行,包括4次教育讲座、在AI社区进行6至8小时的服务学习,以及参与者通过正式演讲和与其他急诊科工作人员的非正式交谈来传播所学内容。我们在干预结束时通过小组访谈来衡量该干预对干预参与者的影响。
小组访谈的结果提供了关于干预期间所学内容、其对医护人员的影响以及对干预结构的反馈。总体而言,急诊科医护人员报告称,该干预提高了他们对自身隐性偏见的认识,以及改善与AI患者沟通和护理的方法。要有效且可持续地解决影响AI人群的健康差异问题,还需要进行更多的机构政策和程序变革。
参与的医护人员在干预开始时认识到他们对AI文化缺乏了解,并且很明显,由于这次干预,他们对AI社区的了解、舒适度以及与AI社区的关系都有所增加。