Department of biomedical science, Aksum University, Aksum, Ethiopia.
Department of Educational Development and Research, Faculty of Health, Medicine and Life Sciences, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
BMC Med Educ. 2020 Jan 8;20(1):7. doi: 10.1186/s12909-019-1924-0.
Self-directed learning (SDL) is an appropriate and preferred learning process to prepare students for lifelong learning in their professions and make them stay up-to-date. The purpose of this study was to explore preclinical students following a hybrid curriculum in Ethiopia experiences to SDL and the support of several learning activities from the curriculum on their SDL. A mixed-method research design was employed.
Quantitative data were collected by using a self-administered questionnaire of 80 items measuring students' perceptions on their SDL capability as well as to explore students' views about the influence of components of the curriculum on their SDL. Additional two focus group discussions, each containing eight participants from year-1 and year students, were conducted. The quantitative data were analyzed using SPSS. The focus group discussions were reviewed, coded, and then thematically analyzed.
Our study showed a significant increase in SDL score on comparing students at year-1 with students at year-2 (p = 0.002). Both year-1 and 2 students rated PBL tutorial discussion and tutors had high influence on their individual learning; whereas, other curricular components such as lectures and testes had low influence on their SDL ability. PBL tutorial discussion and module objectives showed strong correlation with students' SDL scores, r = 0.718 & r = 0.648 (p < 0.01), respectively. Besides, PBL tutorial discussion was found strongly correlated with tutors (r = 0.599 (p < 0.01)) and module objectives (r = 0.574 (p < 0.01)). Assessment was highly correlated with lectures (r = 0.595 (p < 0.01)). Findings from qualitative data showed that certain curricular components played role in promoting students' SDL. Tutorials analyzing problems played a major role on students' self-directed learning abilities.
Although the study implied that components of the hybrid curriculum, mainly PBL, could encourage preclinical students' self-directed learning, the curriculum is still not free from teacher-centred culture as the majority of teachers still have high power in deciding the learning process. A further longitudinal study is needed to verify the actual level and ability of medical students' SDL.
自主学习(SDL)是一种合适且受欢迎的学习过程,可以让学生为职业中的终身学习做好准备,并使他们保持最新状态。本研究的目的是探索在埃塞俄比亚,采用混合课程的临床医学预科学生在 SDL 方面的体验,以及课程中的多项学习活动对 SDL 的支持。本研究采用混合方法研究设计。
通过使用 80 项自我管理问卷收集定量数据,该问卷衡量学生对 SDL 能力的看法,并探讨学生对课程各组成部分对 SDL 影响的看法。还进行了两次焦点小组讨论,每个讨论小组由来自一年级和二年级的 8 名学生组成。使用 SPSS 分析定量数据。对焦点小组讨论进行了审查、编码,然后进行了主题分析。
我们的研究表明,在比较一年级学生和二年级学生时,SDL 得分有显著增加(p=0.002)。一年级和二年级学生都认为 PBL 辅导讨论和导师对他们的个人学习有很大影响;而其他课程组成部分,如讲座和考试,对他们的 SDL 能力影响较小。PBL 辅导讨论和模块目标与学生的 SDL 得分呈强相关,r=0.718 和 r=0.648(p<0.01)。此外,PBL 辅导讨论与导师(r=0.599(p<0.01))和模块目标(r=0.574(p<0.01))呈强相关。评估与讲座高度相关(r=0.595(p<0.01))。定性数据的结果表明,某些课程组成部分在促进学生的 SDL 方面发挥了作用。分析问题的辅导课对学生的自主学习能力有重要作用。
尽管研究表明混合课程的组成部分,主要是 PBL,可以鼓励临床医学预科学生的自主学习,但课程仍然没有摆脱以教师为中心的文化,因为大多数教师仍然在决定学习过程方面拥有很大的权力。需要进一步进行纵向研究,以验证医学生 SDL 的实际水平和能力。