Honno Katsumi, Kubo Tatsuhiko, Toyokuni Yoshiki, Ishimaru Tomohiro, Matsuda Shinya, Fujino Yoshihisa
Department of Public Health School of Medicine University of Occupational and Environmental Health Kitakyushu Japan.
Department of Public Health and Health Policy Graduate School of Biomedical and Health Sciences Hiroshima University Hiroshima Japan.
Acute Med Surg. 2019 Oct 27;7(1):e463. doi: 10.1002/ams2.463. eCollection 2020 Jan-Dec.
A depressive state is a key risk factor for medical errors made by emergency life-saving technicians (ELSTs). However, no study has examined the occurrence of near-misses in ELSTs. We investigated the association between a depressive state and near-misses among ELSTs.
A cross-sectional study was undertaken in 345 ELSTs using an anonymous self-administered questionnaire. The main exposure was a depressive state that was measured using the Quick Inventory of Depressive Symptomatology. For the main outcome, near-miss events, we calculated odds ratios (OR) of depressive states, adjusted for age and work-related factors by multivariable logistic regression. For exploratory purposes, we also undertook secondary analyses to determine whether work-related factors were associated with a depressive state.
We obtained 254 responses. Compared to ELSTs without a depressive state, the adjusted OR for near-misses among ELSTs with a mild depressive state was 3.14 (95% confidence interval [CI], 1.37-7.16; = 0.007), and that among ELSTs with a moderate or greater depressive state was 5.29 (95% CI, 1.46-19.09; = 0.011). For a depressive state, in the exploratory analyses, the OR of nap duration while on duty for less than 2 h was 3.34 (95% CI, 1.15-9.67; = 0.027), that for irregular mealtime while on duty was 3.71 (95% CI, 2.00-6.86; < 0.001), and that for a duration of desk work of 4 h or longer was 2.21 (95% CI, 1.15-4.25; = 0.017).
A depressive state was significantly associated with the occurrence of near-misses among ELSTs. That a depressive state among ELSTs was related to nap duration and excessive office work indicates that improved management of the work environment and operations of ELSTs is necessary for the provision of safe emergency medical services.
抑郁状态是急救技术人员(ELSTs)发生医疗差错的关键风险因素。然而,尚无研究调查过ELSTs中未遂失误的发生情况。我们调查了ELSTs中抑郁状态与未遂失误之间的关联。
采用匿名自填式问卷对345名ELSTs进行了横断面研究。主要暴露因素是使用抑郁症状快速自评量表测量的抑郁状态。对于主要结局——未遂失误事件,我们通过多变量逻辑回归计算了抑郁状态的比值比(OR),并对年龄和工作相关因素进行了校正。出于探索目的,我们还进行了二次分析,以确定工作相关因素是否与抑郁状态有关。
我们获得了254份回复。与无抑郁状态的ELSTs相比,轻度抑郁状态的ELSTs发生未遂失误的校正OR为3.14(95%置信区间[CI],1.37 - 7.16;P = 0.007),中度或重度抑郁状态的ELSTs发生未遂失误的校正OR为5.29(95%CI,1.46 - 19.09;P = 0.011)。在探索性分析中,对于抑郁状态,值班时小睡时间少于2小时的OR为3.34(95%CI,1.15 - 9.67;P = 0.027),值班时用餐时间不规律的OR为3.71(95%CI,2.00 - 6.86;P < 0.001),伏案工作时间4小时或更长的OR为2.21(95%CI,1.15 - 4.25;P = 0.017)。
抑郁状态与ELSTs中未遂失误的发生显著相关。ELSTs的抑郁状态与小睡时间和过多的办公室工作有关,这表明改善ELSTs的工作环境管理和工作流程对于提供安全的紧急医疗服务是必要的。