Comparison of sewage sludge mono-incinerators: Mass balance and distribution of heavy metals in step grate and fluidized bed incinerators.

We investigated the distribution of 18 elements including non-volatiles (Al, P, Ca, Fe, Mg, K, Mn, Cu, Na, Cr, and Ni), semi-volatiles (Zn, Pb, Ag, As, and Cd), and volatiles (Hg and S) and compared their behaviors in two types of full-scale sewage sludge mono-incinerators, namely, a step-grate stoker (GS) and two fluidized bed incinerators (F-types), with the same feed sludge. Most of the non-volatile elements were enriched five-fold in all incinerated sewage sludge ash (ISSA), while the volatile S and Hg were barely enriched in ash due to the combustion components generated in the gas phase. While the semi-volatile elements were also enriched five-fold in the F-types, a different enrichment behavior was observed in the GS. Boiler and multi-cyclone dust in the GS showed higher enrichments of Pb and Cd compared to ash due to the combined effects of lower temperature and smaller particle size. Compared to the F-types, the GS generated ashes with lower toxicity as the major component (99.7%) and hazardous dust as the minor component. In the future, more attention should be paid to grate stokers in terms of recycling ISSA.