J.Q. Young is professor, Department of Psychiatry, Donald and Barbara Zucker School of Medicine at Hofstra/Northwell, Hempstead, New York.
M. McClure is chief resident, Department of Psychiatry, Donald and Barbara Zucker School of Medicine at Hofstra/Northwell, Hempstead, New York.
Acad Med. 2020 Oct;95(10):1546-1549. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000003390.
Entrustable professional activities (EPAs) can be used to operationalize competency-based medical education. Mobile apps can efficiently capture feedback based on direct observation. To leverage the benefits of both, the authors developed an assessment tool that combines EPAs with mobile technology.
The authors designed an app to collect EPA data based on direct observation using human-technology interface guidelines. Data collected in the app included: name of resident, the 13 end-of-training EPAs for psychiatry, entrustment ratings, and corrective narrative feedback. The app was implemented in an outpatient continuity clinic for second-year psychiatry residents over a 10-month period between September 2017 and June 2018. Ten faculty-resident dyads piloted the app. To assess the feasibility, utility, and validity of this intervention, the authors examined 3 outcomes: (1) utilization (mean time to complete each assessment; percentage of dyads who completed 10 assessments), (2) quality of the comments (proportion of comments that were behaviorally specific and actionable), and (3) correlation between entrustment level and resident experience (defined as days elapsed since the beginning of the experience).
A total of 99 assessments were completed during the pilot. Mean time to complete an assessment was 76 seconds (standard deviation = 50 seconds, median = 67 seconds). Only 6 of the 10 dyads completed at least 10 assessments. Of all comments, 95% (94) were behaviorally specific and actionable and 91% (90) were corrective. Entrustment scores correlated moderately with resident experience (r = 0.43, P < .001).
The authors' EPA mobile app was efficient, generated high-quality feedback, and produced entrustment scores that improved as the residents gained experience. Challenges included uneven adoption. Looking forward, the authors plan to examine the enablers and barriers to adoption from an implementation science perspective.
可委托的专业活动(EPAs)可用于实现以能力为基础的医学教育。移动应用程序可以有效地基于直接观察来获取反馈。为了充分利用这两者的优势,作者开发了一种将 EPAs 与移动技术相结合的评估工具。
作者设计了一个应用程序,该应用程序基于使用人机界面指南的直接观察收集 EPA 数据。应用程序中收集的数据包括:住院医师姓名、精神病学培训结束时的 13 项 EPA、委托评级和纠正性叙述性反馈。该应用程序于 2017 年 9 月至 2018 年 6 月在为期 10 个月的第二年精神病学住院医师门诊连续性诊所中实施。10 对教师-住院医师对该应用程序进行了试点。为了评估这种干预措施的可行性、实用性和有效性,作者检查了 3 个结果:(1)利用率(完成每项评估的平均时间;完成 10 项评估的配对比例),(2)评论的质量(评论中行为具体且可操作的比例),以及(3)委托级别与住院医师经验之间的相关性(定义为经验开始以来的天数)。
在试点期间共完成了 99 次评估。完成一次评估的平均时间为 76 秒(标准差=50 秒,中位数=67 秒)。只有 10 对中的 6 对完成了至少 10 次评估。所有评论中,95%(94)是行为具体且可操作的,91%(90)是纠正性的。委托评分与住院医师经验中度相关(r=0.43,P<.001)。
作者的 EPA 移动应用程序高效、生成高质量反馈,并随着住院医师获得经验而提高委托评分。面临的挑战包括采用不均衡。展望未来,作者计划从实施科学的角度检查采用的促进因素和障碍。