Harrison Jennifer L, O'Toole Siobhan K, Ammen Sue, Ahlmeyer Sean, Harrell Sheera N, Hernandez Jacinda L
California School of Professional Psychology, Alliant International University, Fresno, CA, USA.
Minnesota Department of Human Services Direct Care and Treatment - Forensic Services St. Peter, MN, USA.
Psychiatr Psychol Law. 2020 Jan 23;27(1):1-25. doi: 10.1080/13218719.2018.1485526. eCollection 2020.
The current sexual offender literature focuses on recidivism reduction in an effort to increase public safety. While cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) programs are considered a mainstream treatment method, it is essential to study recidivism as an indicator of treatment effectiveness. This meta-analysis examines research published since 1970 to determine the overall effectiveness of treatments in reducing recidivism among adult male sexual offenders. Decade of implementation and CBT treatment features are also assessed as moderator variables. The results from the 25 studies identified were converted into 42 weighted effect sizes utilizing a random-effects model. Significant overall effect sizes were found for sexual and violent/combination recidivism; however, multiple indices indicate heterogeneity in the effect sizes. Significant differences were found in the overall effectiveness of the treatments by decade, and the treatments delivered during the 1990s were found to be related to lower levels of sexual and violent/combination recidivism.
当前关于性犯罪者的文献聚焦于降低累犯率,以努力提高公共安全。虽然认知行为疗法(CBT)项目被视为一种主流治疗方法,但将累犯率作为治疗效果的指标进行研究至关重要。这项荟萃分析考察了自1970年以来发表的研究,以确定各种治疗方法在降低成年男性性犯罪者累犯率方面的总体效果。实施的年代以及CBT治疗的特征也作为调节变量进行评估。利用随机效应模型,将所确定的25项研究的结果转化为42个加权效应量。在性犯罪和暴力/复合型累犯方面发现了显著的总体效应量;然而,多个指标表明效应量存在异质性。按年代划分,治疗的总体效果存在显著差异,并且发现20世纪90年代实施的治疗与较低水平的性犯罪和暴力/复合型累犯有关。