A.B. Zelenski is assistant professor and director of medical education, Department of Medicine, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, Madison, Wisconsin.
N. Saldivar is chair, Department of Theatre, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, and executive director, Nevada Conservatory Theatre, Las Vegas, Nevada.
Acad Med. 2020 Aug;95(8):1210-1214. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000003420.
Health professionals need to learn how to relate to one another to ensure high-quality patient care and to create collaborative and supportive teams in the clinical environment. One method for addressing both of these goals is teaching empathy during professional training to foster connection and commonality across differences. The authors describe a pilot improvisational theater (improv) course and present the preliminary outcomes showing its impact on interprofessional empathy.
In 2016-2017, the authors piloted a 15-hour course to teach interprofessional empathy to health professions students at the University of Wisconsin-Madison using improv techniques. The authors used a convergent mixed-methods design to evaluate the course's impact on interprofessional empathy. Students enrolled in the course (intervention group, n = 45) and a comparison group (n = 41) completed 2 validated empathy questionnaires (Interpersonal Reactivity Index [IRI], Consultative and Relational Empathy [CARE] measure) and a facial expression recognition task to measure empathy in the pre- and postintervention periods. Differences were examined using paired t tests. Semistructured interviews were conducted with 8 course participants to gain a deeper understanding of the course's effects.
The intervention group's mean scores on 5 CARE items improved significantly: ease, care, explain, help, and plan. On the IRI, personal distress levels decreased significantly in both the intervention and comparison groups. In the interviews, students who took the class reported a positive impact on their interprofessional relationships and on their ability to think on their feet. They also reported improv influenced other areas of their lives, including patient care and interactions with people outside their work life.
The authors have continued to offer the course. They aim to conduct a randomized controlled study with medical students and test durability by measuring empathy again 3-6 months following the intervention.
医疗专业人员需要学会相互协作,以确保提供高质量的患者护理,并在临床环境中创建协作和支持性的团队。实现这两个目标的一种方法是在专业培训中教授同理心,以促进不同背景下的联系和共性。作者描述了一个试点即兴戏剧(即兴表演)课程,并介绍了初步结果,展示了其对跨专业同理心的影响。
2016-2017 年,作者在威斯康星大学麦迪逊分校使用即兴表演技术为医疗保健专业的学生试点了一门 15 小时的课程,以教授跨专业同理心。作者采用收敛混合方法设计来评估该课程对跨专业同理心的影响。参加该课程的学生(干预组,n=45)和对照组(n=41)在干预前后完成了 2 个经过验证的同理心问卷(人际反应指数[IRI],咨询和关系同理心[CARE]量表)和面部表情识别任务,以衡量同理心。使用配对 t 检验检查差异。对 8 名课程参与者进行半结构化访谈,以更深入地了解课程的效果。
干预组在 5 项 CARE 项目上的平均分明显提高:轻松、关心、解释、帮助和计划。在 IRI 上,干预组和对照组的个人困扰水平都显著下降。在访谈中,参加该课程的学生报告说,这对他们的跨专业关系以及他们随机应变的能力产生了积极影响。他们还报告说,即兴表演也影响了他们生活的其他领域,包括患者护理和与工作以外的人的互动。
作者继续提供该课程。他们计划与医学生进行随机对照研究,并通过在干预后 3-6 个月再次测量同理心来测试其耐久性。