Department of Civil Engineering and Centre for Environmental Science and Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur, Kanpur, 208016, India.
Department of Civil Engineering and Centre for Environmental Science and Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur, Kanpur, 208016, India.
Chemosphere. 2020 Sep;255:126971. doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.126971. Epub 2020 May 7.
A simple mass-based emission inventory (EI) of PM alone does not provide the information on the toxicity of the sources, as not all PM particles are equally toxic. The PM EI should have three inter-linked versions (i) mass-based, (ii) constituent-based and (iii) source toxicity-based. A framework (applied to the city of Delhi) to prepare constituent and source toxicity-based EI was developed. Mass emission of twelve sources was estimated for 89 constituents. The USEPA's CompTox database was used to estimate threshold concentration for the constituents of PM for carcinogenic, chronic and acute health effects. A product of mass emission of the constituent and inverse of its threshold concentration provides an assessment of toxicity of the source. Toxicity was not linearly associated with the mass emission. Road dust, vehicles, coal, dung, wood and coal power plant showed the highest toxicity as presence of metals Cr, Co, Cd, and As make these sources disproportionately more toxic. Among PAHs, Dibenzo (ah)anthracene, showed the highest cancer risk with its 98% emission from vehicles. The soft options replacing wood, crop, coal and dung with LPG, elimination of diesel power generation, burning of waste were simple and effective measures to reduce chronic toxicity by about 40%.
单纯基于质量的 PM 排放清单(EI)并不能提供有关污染源毒性的信息,因为并非所有 PM 颗粒的毒性都相同。PM EI 应该有三个相互关联的版本:(i)基于质量的,(ii)基于成分的和(iii)基于源毒性的。为编制基于成分和源毒性的 EI,开发了一个框架(应用于德里市)。对 89 种成分的 12 种来源的质量排放量进行了估算。USEPA 的 CompTox 数据库用于估算 PM 成分的致癌、慢性和急性健康影响的阈值浓度。成分的质量排放量与阈值浓度的倒数的乘积提供了对源毒性的评估。毒性与质量排放量没有线性关联。道路灰尘、车辆、煤炭、粪便、木材和燃煤电厂的毒性最高,因为这些源中存在 Cr、Co、Cd 和 As 等金属,使这些源的毒性不成比例地更高。在多环芳烃中,二苯并(a)蒽的致癌风险最高,其 98%来自车辆。用液化石油气替代木材、作物、煤炭和粪便、消除柴油发电、焚烧废物等软性选择是减少慢性毒性约 40%的简单有效措施。