Yunus Maliha, Ghani Zeeshan, Ch Ihtasham Muhammad, Akram Ayesha
Prof. Dr. Maliha Yunus, MBBS, FCPS, MHPE. Professor of Surgery, Al-Nafees Medical College & Hospital, Isra University, Islamabad Campus, Pakistan.
Dr. Zeeshan Ghani, MBBS, FCPS, MCPS. Associate Professor of Paediatrics, Al-Nafees Medical College & Hospital, Isra University, Islamabad Campus, Pakistan.
Pak J Med Sci. 2020 May-Jun;36(4):609-614. doi: 10.12669/pjms.36.4.1792.
To evaluate the effectiveness of basic surgical skill workshop at under graduate level.
This was randomized controlled study (cross-over design) conducted at Al-Nafees Medical College and hospital from 1 January to November 30 2017. Undergraduate medical students of Year-5 MBBS were randomized into two groups to undergo surgical skills training. One was workshop or interventional Group-A, other was traditional teaching or control Group-B. Online random sampling calculator was used for randomization. Both groups were given a pretest and post-test in the form of two OSATS station.
Total 49 students were enrolled in the study; Group-A had 25 whereas Group-B had 24 students. There was significant difference (=0.000) in mean post-test scores of Group-A (36.28±6.75) and Group-B (24.17±5.09) out of 53 on OSATS station-1. Significant statistical difference (p=0.000) in the mean score of post-tests of Group-A (26.08±18.34) and Group-B (14.42±9.24) out of 37 was also noted on OSATS station-2. There was no significant difference in mean pretest scores on both stations in both groups.
This study has suggestions in development of curriculum as it provides a quantitative substantiation indicating that workshop teaching as a learning strategy can essentially augment traditional teaching of technical skills to undergraduate medical students.
评估本科阶段基础外科技能工作坊的有效性。
这是一项于2017年1月1日至11月30日在纳菲斯医学院及医院进行的随机对照研究(交叉设计)。将本科五年级医学学士学生随机分为两组接受外科技能培训。一组是工作坊或干预组A,另一组是传统教学或对照组B。使用在线随机抽样计算器进行随机分组。两组均以两个客观结构化外科技能评估(OSATS)站点的形式进行了预测试和后测试。
共有49名学生参与该研究;A组有25名学生,而B组有24名学生。在OSATS站点1上,A组(36.28±6.75)和B组(24.17±5.09)的平均后测成绩(满分53分)存在显著差异(=0.000)。在OSATS站点2上,A组(26.08±18.34)和B组(14.42±9.24)的平均后测成绩(满分37分)也存在显著统计学差异(p=0.000)。两组在两个站点的平均预测试成绩均无显著差异。
本研究对课程开发具有启示意义,因为它提供了定量证据,表明工作坊教学作为一种学习策略可以从本质上增强对本科医学生技术技能的传统教学。