Mannheim Centre for European Social Research, University of Mannheim.
Department of Psychology, University of Cambridge.
J Pers Soc Psychol. 2021 Aug;121(2):378-393. doi: 10.1037/pspp0000344. Epub 2020 Jun 29.
Interactionist theories are considered to have resolved the classic person-situation debate by demonstrating that human behavior is most accurately described as a function of both personal characteristics as well as environmental cues. According to these theories, personality traits form part of the personal characteristics that drive behavior. We suggest that psychological theory stands to gain from also considering personality traits as an important environmental characteristic that shapes sociocultural norms and institutions, and, in turn, behavior. Building on research in geographical psychology, we support this proposition by presenting evidence on the relationship of individual and regional personality with spending behavior. Analyzing the spending records of 111,336 participants (31,915,942 unique transactions) across 374 Local Authority Districts (LAD) in the United Kingdom, we first show that geographic regions with higher aggregate scores on a given personality trait collectively spend more money on categories associated with that trait. Shifting the focus to individual level spending as our behavioral outcome ( = 1,716), we further demonstrate that regional personality of a participant's home LAD predicts individual spending above and beyond individual personality. That is, a person's spending reflects both their own personality traits as well as the personality traits of the people around them. We use conditional random forest predictions to highlight the robustness of these findings in the presence of a comprehensive set of individual and regional control variables. Taken together, our findings empirically support the proposition that spending behaviors reflect personality traits as both personal and environmental characteristics. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2021 APA, all rights reserved).
交互理论被认为通过证明人类行为最准确地描述为个人特征和环境线索的函数,从而解决了经典的人与情境的争论。根据这些理论,人格特质是驱动行为的个人特征的一部分。我们认为,心理理论也可以从将人格特质视为塑造社会文化规范和制度,进而影响行为的重要环境特征中获益。我们基于地理心理学的研究,通过展示个体和区域人格特质与消费行为之间关系的证据来支持这一主张。在分析了英国 374 个地方行政区(LAD)的 111336 名参与者(31915942 笔唯一交易)的消费记录后,我们首先表明,在给定人格特质上具有较高总分的地理区域总体上在与该特质相关的类别上花费更多的钱。将个人消费作为我们的行为结果(n=1716),我们进一步证明,参与者所在 LAD 的区域人格特质可以预测个人消费,而不仅仅是个人人格特质。也就是说,一个人的消费既反映了他们自己的人格特质,也反映了他们周围人的人格特质。我们使用条件随机森林预测来突出这些发现的稳健性,因为它们存在一整套个人和区域控制变量。总之,我们的研究结果从经验上支持了这样一种观点,即消费行为反映了人格特质,既是个人特征也是环境特征。(PsycInfo 数据库记录(c)2021 APA,保留所有权利)。