Soares-Yoshikawa Aline Laignier, Cury Jaime Aparecido, Tabchoury Cínthia Pereira Machado
Department of Biosciences, Piracicaba Dental School, Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Piracicaba, SP, Brazil.
Braz Dent J. 2020 Jun;31(3):257-263. doi: 10.1590/0103-6440202003669. Epub 2020 Jul 13.
The aim of this in vitro study was to determine the fluoride concentration in silver diamine fluoride (SDF) products and their bioavailability with demineralized dentine. The products evaluated (expected fluoride concentrations) were: I: Saforide 38% (45,283 ppm F); II: Advantage Arrest 38.3 to 43.2% (45,283 to 51,013 ppm F); III: Ancárie 12% (14,100 ppm F); IV: Ancárie 30% (35,400 ppm F), V: Cariestop 12% (14,100 ppm F) and VI: Cariestop 30% (35,400 ppm F). The fluoride concentration was evaluated using an ion-specific electrode (ISE) by direct technique, which was confirmed after microdiffusion. The pH of the products was determined with a pH test strip. For the bioavailability test, demineralized dentine slabs were treated with one of the products for 1 min. Loosely (CaF2-like) and firmly-bound fluoride (FAp) were determined. The fluoride concentration found in the products (mean±SD; ppm F) by the ISE direct technique was: I:53,491±554; II:57,249±1,851; III:4,814±268; IV:5,726±43; V:10,145±468; VI:11,858±575; these values were confirmed after microdiffusion (t-test; p>0.05) and disagree with the declared by the manufacturers. The pH of Ancárie 12 and 30% was 6.0 and 4.5, respectively, in disagreement with the alkaline pH expected for SDF solution and found in the other products evaluated. There was no correlation between either CaF2-like (r=0.221; p=0.337) or FAp (r=-0.144; p=0.830) formed in demineralized dentine and fluoride concentration found in the products. The problems of pH and fluoride concentration found in available professional commercial SDF products suggest that they are not under sanitary surveillance.
本体外研究的目的是测定氟化银胺(SDF)产品中的氟化物浓度及其与脱矿牙本质的生物利用度。所评估的产品(预期氟化物浓度)为:I:Saforide 38%(45,283 ppm F);II:Advantage Arrest 38.3%至43.2%(45,283至51,013 ppm F);III:Ancárie 12%(14,100 ppm F);IV:Ancárie 30%(35,400 ppm F);V:Cariestop 12%(14,100 ppm F);VI:Cariestop 30%(35,400 ppm F)。使用离子特异性电极(ISE)通过直接技术评估氟化物浓度,微扩散后得到证实。用pH试纸测定产品的pH值。对于生物利用度测试,将脱矿牙本质薄片用其中一种产品处理1分钟。测定松散结合(类CaF2)和牢固结合的氟化物(FAp)。通过ISE直接技术在产品中发现的氟化物浓度(平均值±标准差;ppm F)为:I:53,491±554;II:57,249±1,851;III:4,814±268;IV:5,726±43;V:10,145±468;VI:11,858±575;微扩散后(t检验;p>0.05)证实了这些值,且与制造商宣称的值不一致。Ancárie 12%和30%的pH值分别为6.0和4.5,这与SDF溶液预期的碱性pH值以及在其他评估产品中发现的pH值不一致。在脱矿牙本质中形成的类CaF2(r = 0.221;p = 0.337)或FAp(r = -0.144;p = 0.830)与产品中发现的氟化物浓度之间均无相关性。市售专业SDF产品中发现的pH值和氟化物浓度问题表明它们未受到卫生监管。