Choudhury Avishek, Asan Onur
School of Systems and Enterprises, Stevens Institute of Technology, Hoboken, NJ, United States.
JMIR Med Inform. 2020 Jul 24;8(7):e18599. doi: 10.2196/18599.
Artificial intelligence (AI) provides opportunities to identify the health risks of patients and thus influence patient safety outcomes.
The purpose of this systematic literature review was to identify and analyze quantitative studies utilizing or integrating AI to address and report clinical-level patient safety outcomes.
We restricted our search to the PubMed, PubMed Central, and Web of Science databases to retrieve research articles published in English between January 2009 and August 2019. We focused on quantitative studies that reported positive, negative, or intermediate changes in patient safety outcomes using AI apps, specifically those based on machine-learning algorithms and natural language processing. Quantitative studies reporting only AI performance but not its influence on patient safety outcomes were excluded from further review.
We identified 53 eligible studies, which were summarized concerning their patient safety subcategories, the most frequently used AI, and reported performance metrics. Recognized safety subcategories were clinical alarms (n=9; mainly based on decision tree models), clinical reports (n=21; based on support vector machine models), and drug safety (n=23; mainly based on decision tree models). Analysis of these 53 studies also identified two essential findings: (1) the lack of a standardized benchmark and (2) heterogeneity in AI reporting.
This systematic review indicates that AI-enabled decision support systems, when implemented correctly, can aid in enhancing patient safety by improving error detection, patient stratification, and drug management. Future work is still needed for robust validation of these systems in prospective and real-world clinical environments to understand how well AI can predict safety outcomes in health care settings.
人工智能(AI)为识别患者的健康风险并进而影响患者安全结果提供了机会。
本系统文献综述的目的是识别和分析利用或整合人工智能来解决和报告临床层面患者安全结果的定量研究。
我们将搜索范围限制在PubMed、PubMed Central和Web of Science数据库,以检索2009年1月至2019年8月期间以英文发表的研究文章。我们专注于使用人工智能应用程序报告患者安全结果出现正向、负向或中间变化的定量研究,特别是那些基于机器学习算法和自然语言处理的应用程序。仅报告人工智能性能而未报告其对患者安全结果影响的定量研究被排除在进一步审查之外。
我们识别出53项符合条件的研究,并根据其患者安全子类别、最常用的人工智能以及报告的性能指标进行了总结。公认的安全子类别包括临床警报(n = 9;主要基于决策树模型)、临床报告(n = 21;基于支持向量机模型)和药物安全(n = 23;主要基于决策树模型)。对这53项研究的分析还发现了两个重要结果:(1)缺乏标准化基准;(2)人工智能报告的异质性。
本系统综述表明,正确实施的人工智能决策支持系统可以通过改善错误检测、患者分层和药物管理来帮助提高患者安全。未来仍需要在前瞻性和真实世界临床环境中对这些系统进行有力验证,以了解人工智能在医疗环境中预测安全结果的能力如何。