Miller J Mitchell, Blumstein Alfred
University of North Florida, Jacksonville, FL USA.
Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213 USA.
Am J Crim Justice. 2020;45(4):515-524. doi: 10.1007/s12103-020-09555-z. Epub 2020 Jul 9.
The novel corona virus COVID-19 has become a worldwide public health pandemic that has induced anomic conditions impacting daily routines. COVID-19 response measures specifically alter regular schedules and both restrict and expand opportunities for various types of crime while presenting unprecedented challenges for the criminal justice system. For criminologists and criminal justice scientists, the virus also presents natural experiment conditions allowing for real-world theory tests and observation of the relative effectiveness of practice and policy options under weighty conditions. Toward synthesizing scientific discourse and forthcoming empirical work, we suggest the benefits of a COVID-19 crime and justice research program and offer some anchoring concepts. Contagion, containment measures (social distancing, facemasks, shelter-in-place, economic shutdown, virtual work and schooling, banned group gatherings), and social ordinance compliance (voluntary or enforced) posture a conceptual framework from which to align research on crime, justice, and victimization during the virus. After observing crime trends and justice system challenges, we suggest how the pandemic presents opportunities for review of various criminal justice, especially incarceration, policies. System change is a recurring theme across this special issue of the American Journal of Criminal Justice that features twenty additional contributions from a wide range of authoritative crime and justice scholars. These articles on traditional crime during the virus, virus specific hate crime and domestic violence, and the challenges posed by COVID-19 to law enforcement, the courts, and corrections will hopefully provide initial commentary toward deeper inquiry.
新型冠状病毒COVID-19已成为一场全球公共卫生大流行病,引发了影响日常生活的混乱状况。COVID-19应对措施特别改变了常规日程安排,既限制又扩大了各类犯罪的机会,同时给刑事司法系统带来了前所未有的挑战。对于犯罪学家和刑事司法科学家而言,这种病毒还提供了自然实验条件,可用于进行现实世界的理论测试,并观察在严峻条件下实践和政策选项的相对有效性。为了综合科学论述和即将开展的实证研究工作,我们提出了一个COVID-19犯罪与司法研究项目的益处,并提供了一些基础概念。传染、遏制措施(社交距离、戴口罩、就地避难、经济停摆、虚拟工作和学习、禁止群体聚集)以及社会秩序遵守情况(自愿或强制)构成了一个概念框架,据此可以对病毒期间的犯罪、司法和受害情况研究进行整合。在观察了犯罪趋势和司法系统面临的挑战之后,我们提出了疫情如何为审视各种刑事司法政策,尤其是监禁政策,提供了机会。系统变革是《美国刑事司法杂志》这一特刊中反复出现的主题,该特刊还收录了来自众多权威犯罪与司法学者的另外二十篇文章。这些关于病毒期间传统犯罪、特定于病毒的仇恨犯罪和家庭暴力,以及COVID-19给执法、法院和惩教带来的挑战的文章,有望为更深入的探究提供初步评论。