Department of Community Health Nursing, College of Nursing, Taibah University.
Department of Communication, Wayne State University.
Health Commun. 2022 Jan;37(1):20-28. doi: 10.1080/10410236.2020.1813954. Epub 2020 Sep 2.
This systematic and meta-analytic review investigated the effects of media health literacy (MHL) interventions in school settings on adolescents' body image. Twenty one intervention-control comparisons reported in 16 studies were identified. The following attributes were extracted from each study for a systematic review: Study time-period and country location, sample composition, school atmosphere, unit of random assignment, theoretical perspective, intervention-control comparison, co-interventions, number of overall and MHL sessions, length of MHL sessions, and outcomes measured. The meta-analysis of effect sizes for three outcomes of interest related to body image showed consistent changes in the desired negative direction as expected: body image concerns ( = -0.25, = 19); eating concerns ( = -0.18, = 19); thin-internalization attitudes ( = -0.40, = 12); and combined ( = -0.25, = 21). Homogeneity analysis for the combined effect size and moderator analyses for gender composition of intervention group, number of overall intervention sessions, number of MHL specific intervention sessions within the overall intervention, and time length of MHL intervention session all showed absence of moderators. However, all study samples except one were of European origin and so caution should be exercised when generalizing to other cultures that may have different standards of female ideal body type.
本系统评价和荟萃分析研究了学校环境中媒体健康素养 (MHL) 干预对青少年体像的影响。从 16 项研究中确定了 21 项干预对照比较。从每项研究中提取以下属性进行系统评价:研究时间和国家/地区、样本组成、学校氛围、随机分组单位、理论视角、干预对照比较、联合干预、总体和 MHL 课程的数量、MHL 课程的长度以及测量的结果。对与体像相关的三个感兴趣结果的效应大小进行荟萃分析,结果显示与预期一致的朝着期望的负面方向变化:体像担忧( = -0.25, = 19);饮食担忧( = -0.18, = 19);瘦内化态度( = -0.40, = 12);以及综合( = -0.25, = 21)。对综合效应大小的同质性分析以及对干预组中性别组成、总体干预课程数量、总体干预中特定 MHL 干预课程数量以及 MHL 干预课程时间长度的调节因子分析均表明不存在调节因子。然而,除了一项研究外,所有研究样本均来自欧洲,因此在推广到可能具有不同女性理想体型标准的其他文化时应谨慎行事。