Department of reproductive medicine, Bordeaux University Hospital, Hôpital Pellegrin, Place Amélie Raba-Léon, 33076 Bordeaux, France; Reproductive Center, Polyclinique Saint Roch, 550 avenue du colonel André Pavelet, 34070 Montpellier, France.
Department of reproductive medicine, Bordeaux University Hospital, Hôpital Pellegrin, Place Amélie Raba-Léon, 33076 Bordeaux, France.
J Gynecol Obstet Hum Reprod. 2020 Nov;49(9):101902. doi: 10.1016/j.jogoh.2020.101902. Epub 2020 Sep 1.
France is known for its conservative and unique position in assisted reproductive technologies (ARTs). At the eve of the future revision of French Bioethics laws, we decided to conduct a national survey to examine the opinions of French specialists in ARTs about social issues.
Descriptive study conducted in May 2017 in a university teaching hospital using an anonymous online questionnaire on current issues in ARTs. The questionnaire was sent by email to 650 French ARTs specialists, both clinicians and embryologists.
After 3 reminders, 408 responses were collected resulting in a participation rate of 62.7% (408/650). Concerning pre-implantation genetic testing, 80% of the physicians were in favor of expanding the indications, which in France are presently limited to incurable genetic diseases. Authorizing elective Fertility Preservation was supported by 93.4% of the specialists, but without social coverage for 86.3% of them. Concerning gamete donation, 77.4% of the French ARTs specialists were in favor of giving a financial compensation to donors, 92% promoted preserving their anonymity and 80.9% were against a directed donation. ARTs for single heterosexual women were supported by 63.4% of the French specialists and by 72.5% for lesbian couples. The legalization of surrogacy was requested by 55.2%.
Pending the revision of the French Bioethics laws, this survey provides an overview of the opinion of the specialists in ARTs on expanding ARTs for various social indications.Because of the evolution of social values, a more liberal and inclusive ART program is desired by the majority of ART specialists in France.
法国在辅助生殖技术(ART)方面以其保守和独特的立场而闻名。在未来修订法国生物伦理法之际,我们决定进行一项全国性调查,以了解法国 ART 专家对社会问题的看法。
这是一项于 2017 年 5 月在一所大学教学医院进行的描述性研究,采用匿名在线问卷形式调查 ART 领域当前的问题。问卷通过电子邮件发送给 650 名法国 ART 专家,包括临床医生和胚胎学家。
经过 3 次提醒,共收到 408 份回复,参与率为 62.7%(408/650)。关于植入前遗传检测,80%的医生赞成扩大适应症,目前法国的适应症仅限于无法治愈的遗传疾病。93.4%的专家支持授权选择性生育力保存,但其中 86.3%的专家不希望对此提供社会覆盖。关于配子捐赠,77.4%的法国 ART 专家赞成给予捐赠者经济补偿,92%的专家赞成保护他们的匿名性,80.9%的专家反对定向捐赠。63.4%的法国专家支持单身异性恋女性的 ART,72.5%的专家支持女同性恋夫妇的 ART。55.2%的专家要求代孕合法化。
在修订法国生物伦理法之际,这项调查提供了法国 ART 专家对扩大各种社会适应症的 ART 的意见概述。由于社会价值观的演变,大多数法国 ART 专家希望制定一个更加自由和包容的 ART 计划。