Department of Neurosurgery, UConn School of Medicine, Farmington, Connecticut, USA.
College of Medicine, University of Tennessee Health Sciences Center, Memphis, Tennessee, USA.
World Neurosurg. 2020 Dec;144:e428-e437. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2020.08.187. Epub 2020 Sep 2.
Surgical education has increasingly relied on electronic learning. In particular, online operative videos have become a core resource within neurosurgery. We analyze the forums for neurosurgical operative videos.
Operative videos from 5 sources were reviewed: 1) the NEUROSURGERY Journal YouTube channel; 2) the American Association of Neurological Surgeons Neurosurgery YouTube channel; 3) The Neurosurgical Atlas Operative Video Cases; 4) Operative Neurosurgery; and 5) Neurosurgical Focus: Video. Title, year of publication, senior author, institution, country, and subspecialty were documented for each video.
A total of 1233 videos showing 1247 surgeries were identified. Ten videos included >1 surgery; of those, there was a median of 2 surgeries (interquartile range, 2.0-2.5) per video. The most frequently represented subspecialties included vascular (48.3%), tumor (35.2%), and skull base surgery (27.5%), with almost 40% of videos showing >1 category. Videos were submitted by investigators from 28 countries, but 82.1% of the videos originated in the United States.
Neurosurgical operative videos have become increasingly common through a variety of online platforms. Future efforts may benefit from collecting videos from underrepresented regions and subspecialties, providing long-term follow-up data and showing techniques for managing complications.
外科教育越来越依赖电子学习。特别是,在线手术视频已成为神经外科的核心资源。我们分析了神经外科手术视频的论坛。
对来自 5 个来源的手术视频进行了回顾:1)《神经外科杂志》YouTube 频道;2)美国神经外科学会神经外科 YouTube 频道;3)神经外科图谱手术视频病例;4)手术神经外科;和 5)神经外科焦点:视频。记录了每个视频的标题、出版年份、资深作者、机构、国家和亚专业。
共确定了 1233 个显示 1247 个手术的视频。其中 10 个视频包含>1 个手术;其中,每个视频的中位数为 2 个手术(四分位距,2.0-2.5)。最常代表的亚专业包括血管(48.3%)、肿瘤(35.2%)和颅底手术(27.5%),近 40%的视频显示>1 个类别。视频由来自 28 个国家的研究人员提交,但 82.1%的视频来自美国。
神经外科手术视频已通过各种在线平台变得越来越普遍。未来的工作可能受益于收集来自代表性不足的地区和亚专业的视频,提供长期随访数据,并展示处理并发症的技术。