Knowledge Synthesis Group, Clinical Epidemiology Program, Ottawa Hospital Research Institute, Canada; TRIBE Graduate Program, University of Split School of Medicine, Croatia.
Cochrane Austria, Danube University Krems, Krems a.d. Donau, Austria; RTI International, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA.
J Clin Epidemiol. 2021 Feb;130:13-22. doi: 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.10.007. Epub 2020 Oct 15.
To develop methods guidance to support the conduct of rapid reviews (RRs) produced within Cochrane and beyond, in response to requests for timely evidence syntheses for decision-making purposes including urgent health issues of high priority.
Interim recommendations were informed by a scoping review of the underlying evidence, primary methods studies conducted, and a survey sent to 119 representatives from 20 Cochrane entities, who were asked to rate and rank RR methods across stages of review conduct. Discussions among those with expertise in RR methods further informed the list of recommendations with accompanying rationales provided.
Based on survey results from 63 respondents (53% response rate), 26 RR methods recommendations are presented for which there was a high or moderate level of agreement or scored highest in the absence of such agreement. Where possible, how recommendations align with Cochrane methods guidance for systematic reviews is highlighted.
The Cochrane Rapid Reviews Methods Group offers new, interim guidance to support the conduct of RRs. Because best practice is limited by the lack of currently available evidence for some RR methods shortcuts taken, this guidance will need to be updated as additional abbreviated methods are evaluated.
制定方法指南,以支持 Cochrane 及其它组织内部针对决策目的(包括高优先级的紧急卫生问题)及时进行证据综合而开展的快速审查(RR)。
通过对基础证据进行范围审查、对已开展的主要方法研究以及向来自 20 个 Cochrane 实体的 119 名代表进行的调查,为临时建议提供了信息,这些代表被要求对审查过程各阶段的 RR 方法进行评分和排序。RR 方法专家之间的讨论也进一步充实了建议清单,并提供了相应的理由。
根据来自 63 名应答者(53%的应答率)的调查结果,提出了 26 条 RR 方法建议,这些建议在审查过程的各个阶段都得到了高度或中度的一致认可,或者在没有这种一致认可的情况下得分最高。在可能的情况下,还突出显示了建议与 Cochrane 系统评价方法指南的一致性。
Cochrane 快速审查方法小组提供了新的临时指南,以支持 RR 的开展。由于某些 RR 方法的快速通道受到当前可用证据的限制,最佳实践受到限制,因此随着更多简化方法的评估,本指南将需要不断更新。