Stöver T, Zeh R, Gängler B, Plontke S K, Ohligmacher S, Deitmer T, Hupka O, Welkoborsky H J, Schulz M, Delank W, Strobel M, Guntinas-Lichius O, Lang S, Dietz A, Dazert S, Diensthuber M
Klinik für Hals-Nasen-Ohrenheilkunde, Universitätsklinikum Frankfurt a. M.
Deutsche Cochlea Implantat Gesellschaft (DCIG) e. V., Senden.
Laryngorhinootologie. 2020 Dec;99(12):863-871. doi: 10.1055/a-1302-0368. Epub 2020 Nov 9.
The treatment of patients with severe hearing loss or deafness with a cochlear implant (CI) represents a standard in Germany today. However, there is hardly any data on the current number of clinical CI centers (CI clinics) and their geographical distribution. The patient self-help organization, German Cochlear Implant Society (DCIG), and the German Society for Otorhinolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery (DGHNO-KHC) have therefore initiated a survey to determine the regional distribution, the range of services, the consideration of existing quality standards and cooperation with patient self-help organizations of the individual clinical CI centers.For this purpose, a total number of 170 ENT departments or their directors (37 professors and 133 chief physicians), respectively, were contacted by e-mail and provided with a questionnaire. The survey took place from October 2019 to February 2020.Of the 170 departments contacted, 71 (41.8 %) took part in the survey. Of these, 70 departments (98.6 %) confirmed to perform CI surgeries. Thus, 41.8 % of all clinics contacted reported to perform CI surgeries (70 of 170 clinics), while this information was not available from 99 clinics. All 70 clinical CI centers (100 %) reported to conduct CI surgeries on adults, 60 centers (85.7 %) also on children (< 18 years). 36 departments (51.4 %) reported that the total number of CI surgeries at their facility in 2018 was more than 50. In 64 departments (91.4 %), the recommendations of the DGHNO-KHC on CI care (according to the White Paper CI care 2018) were followed. A collaboration between the department and patient self-help organization was confirmed by 67 institutions (95.7 %). The geographical distribution of the clinical CI centers showed a heterogeneous distribution pattern between the individual federal states and also within the respective federal state.The work presented here is a first assessment of the situation with regard to the regional distribution of clinical CI centers in Germany. A clustering of CI centers was noticeable in metropolitan areas, sometimes with several facilities in one city. The predominant attention to quality-related aspects, such as the consideration of the DGHNO-KHC white paper and the cooperation with patient self-help, is gratifying. The limitations of the study result from limited participation in the survey (41.8 % of the contacted clinics).
如今,在德国,使用人工耳蜗(CI)治疗重度听力损失或失聪患者已成为一种标准治疗方法。然而,目前几乎没有关于临床CI中心(CI诊所)的数量及其地理分布的数据。因此,患者自助组织德国人工耳蜗协会(DCIG)和德国耳鼻咽喉头颈外科学会(DGHNO-KHC)发起了一项调查,以确定各个临床CI中心的区域分布、服务范围、对现有质量标准的遵循情况以及与患者自助组织的合作情况。
为此,通过电子邮件联系了总共170个耳鼻喉科科室或其主任(37名教授和133名主任医师),并向他们提供了一份问卷。调查于2019年10月至2020年2月进行。
在被联系的170个科室中,71个(41.8%)参与了调查。其中,70个科室(98.6%)确认开展CI手术。因此,所有被联系诊所中有41.8%(170个诊所中的70个)报告开展CI手术,而99个诊所未提供此信息。所有70个临床CI中心(100%)报告对成人进行CI手术,60个中心(85.7%)也对儿童(<18岁)进行手术。36个科室(51.4%)报告其机构在2018年的CI手术总数超过50例。在64个科室(91.4%)中,遵循了DGHNO-KHC关于CI护理的建议(根据2018年CI护理白皮书)。67个机构(95.7%)确认科室与患者自助组织之间有合作。临床CI中心的地理分布在各个联邦州之间以及各联邦州内部均呈现出不均匀的分布模式。
此处呈现的工作是对德国临床CI中心区域分布情况的首次评估。在大都市地区,CI中心明显聚集,有时一个城市中有多个机构。对与质量相关的方面给予主要关注,例如对DGHNO-KHC白皮书的遵循以及与患者自助组织的合作,这令人欣慰。研究的局限性在于调查参与度有限(被联系诊所的41.8%)。