Department of Research and Evaluation, Kaiser Permanente Southern California, Pasadena, CA, USA.
Division of Internal Medicine, Kaiser Permanente West Los Angeles Medical Center, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
J Gen Intern Med. 2021 Oct;36(10):3015-3022. doi: 10.1007/s11606-020-06493-8. Epub 2021 Jan 19.
High-risk medications pose serious safety risks to older adults, including increasing the risk of falls. Deprescribing potentially inappropriate medications (PIMs) in older adults who have experienced a fall is a key element of fall reduction strategies. However, continued use of PIMs in older adults is common, and clinicians may face substantial deprescribing barriers.
Explore patient and clinician experiences with and perceptions of deprescribing PIMs in patients with a history of falls.
We led guided patient feedback sessions to explore deprescribing scenarios with patient stakeholders and conducted semi-structured interviews with primary care physicians (PCPs) to explore knowledge and awareness of fall risk guidelines, deprescribing experiences, and barriers and facilitators to deprescribing.
PCPs from Kaiser Permanente Southern California (KPSC) and patient members of the KPSC Regional Patient Advisory Committee.
We used maximum variation sampling to identify PCPs with patients who had a fall, then categorized the resulting PIM dispense distribution for those patients into high and low frequency. We analyzed the data using a hybrid deductive-inductive approach. Coders applied initial deductively derived codes to the data, simultaneously using an open-code inductive approach to capture emergent themes.
Physicians perceived deprescribing discussions as potentially contentious, even among patients with falls. Physicians reported varying comfort levels with deprescribing strategies: some felt that the conversations might be better suited to others (e.g., pharmacists), while others had well-planned negotiation strategies. Patients reported lack of clarity as to the reasons and goals of deprescribing and poor understanding of the seriousness of falls.
Our study suggests that key barriers to deprescribing include PCP trepidation about raising a contentious topic and insufficient patient awareness of the potential seriousness of falls. Findings suggest the need for multifaceted, multilevel deprescribing approaches with clinician training strategies, patient educational resources, and a focus on building trusting patient-clinician relationships.
高危药物会给老年人带来严重的安全风险,包括增加跌倒的风险。在曾经跌倒过的老年人中,减少潜在不适当药物(PIMs)的使用是减少跌倒策略的关键要素。然而,老年人继续使用 PIMs 的情况很常见,临床医生可能面临相当大的减少药物使用障碍。
探讨有跌倒史的患者和临床医生对减少 PIMs 使用的体验和看法。
我们引导患者利益相关者进行反馈会议,探讨与减少药物使用相关的场景,并对初级保健医生(PCPs)进行半结构化访谈,探讨他们对跌倒风险指南、减少药物使用的经验、减少药物使用的障碍和促进因素的了解和认识。
来自 Kaiser Permanente Southern California(KPSC)的 PCPs 和 KPSC 区域患者咨询委员会的患者成员。
我们使用最大变异抽样方法,确定有跌倒史的患者的 PCP,并对这些患者的 PIM 配药分布进行高低频分类。我们使用混合演绎归纳法分析数据。编码员将初始演绎法衍生的代码应用于数据,同时采用开放式编码归纳法捕捉新出现的主题。
医生认为减少药物使用的讨论可能存在争议,即使是在有跌倒史的患者中也是如此。医生报告了对减少药物使用策略的舒适度存在差异:一些医生认为这些对话可能更适合其他人(例如药剂师),而另一些医生则有精心策划的谈判策略。患者报告说,他们不清楚减少药物使用的原因和目标,也不了解跌倒的严重性。
我们的研究表明,减少药物使用的主要障碍包括 PCP 对提出有争议性话题的担忧,以及患者对跌倒潜在严重性的认识不足。研究结果表明,需要采取多方面、多层次的减少药物使用方法,包括对临床医生进行培训策略、为患者提供教育资源,并注重建立信任的医患关系。