Beale Sarah, Lewer Dan, Aldridge Robert W, Johnson Anne M, Zambon Maria, Hayward Andrew, Fragaszy Ellen
UCL Public Health Data Science Research Group, UCL Institute of Health Informatics, University College London, London, NW1 2DA, UK.
UCL Research Department of Epidemiology & Public Health, University College London, London, WC1E 7HB, UK.
Wellcome Open Res. 2020 Jun 19;5:145. doi: 10.12688/wellcomeopenres.16055.1. eCollection 2020.
In the context of the current coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, understanding household transmission of seasonal coronaviruses may inform pandemic control. We aimed to investigate what proportion of seasonal coronavirus transmission occurred within households, measure the risk of transmission in households, and describe the impact of household-related factors of risk of transmission. Using data from three winter seasons of the UK Flu Watch cohort study, we measured the proportion of symptomatic infections acquired outside and within the home, the household transmission risk and the household secondary attack risk for PCR-confirmed seasonal coronaviruses. We present transmission risk stratified by demographic features of households. We estimated that the proportion of cases acquired outside the home, weighted by age and region, was 90.7% (95% CI 84.6- 94.5, =173/195) and within the home was 9.3% (5.5-15.4, 22/195). Following a symptomatic coronavirus index case, 14.9% (9.8 - 22.1, 20/134) of households experienced symptomatic transmission to at least one other household member. Onward transmission risk ranged from 11.90% (4.84-26.36, 5/42) to 19.44% (9.21-36.49, 7/36) by strain. The overall household secondary attack risk for symptomatic cases was 8.00% (5.31-11.88, 22/275), ranging across strains from 5.10 (2.11-11.84, 5/98) to 10.14 (4.82- 20.11, 7/69). Median clinical onset serial interval was 7 days (IQR= 6-9.5). Households including older adults, 3+ children, current smokers, contacts with chronic health conditions, and those in relatively deprived areas had the highest transmission risks. Child index cases and male index cases demonstrated the highest transmission risks. Most seasonal coronaviruses appear to be acquired outside the household, with relatively modest risk of onward transmission within households. Transmission risk following an index case appears to vary by demographic household features, with potential overlap between those demonstrating the highest point estimates for seasonal coronavirus transmission risk and COVID-19 susceptibility and poor illness outcomes.
在当前2019冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行的背景下,了解季节性冠状病毒的家庭传播情况可能有助于大流行的控制。我们旨在调查季节性冠状病毒传播在家庭内部发生的比例,测量家庭中的传播风险,并描述与家庭相关的传播风险因素的影响。利用英国流感观察队列研究三个冬季的数据,我们测量了在家庭外和家庭内获得的有症状感染的比例、家庭传播风险以及经聚合酶链反应(PCR)确诊的季节性冠状病毒的家庭二代发病率。我们呈现了按家庭人口特征分层的传播风险。我们估计,按年龄和地区加权后,在家庭外获得的病例比例为90.7%(95%置信区间84.6 - 94.5,173/195),在家庭内获得的病例比例为9.3%(5.5 - 15.4,22/195)。在出现有症状的冠状病毒指示病例后,14.9%(9.8 - 22.1,20/134)的家庭经历了有症状的传播,至少传染给了另一名家庭成员。不同毒株的后续传播风险在11.90%(4.84 - 26.36,5/42)至19.44%(9.21 - 36.49,7/36)之间。有症状病例的总体家庭二代发病率为8.00%(5.31 - 11.88,22/275),不同毒株的发病率在5.10(2.11 - 11.84,5/98)至10.14(4.82 - 20.11,7/69)之间。临床发病的中位连续间隔时间为7天(四分位间距 = 6 - 9.5)。包括老年人、3名及以上儿童、当前吸烟者、有慢性健康状况的接触者以及相对贫困地区人群的家庭传播风险最高。儿童指示病例和男性指示病例的传播风险最高。大多数季节性冠状病毒似乎是在家庭外感染的,家庭内部的后续传播风险相对较小。指示病例后的传播风险似乎因家庭人口特征而异,在季节性冠状病毒传播风险、COVID-19易感性和不良疾病结局方面显示出最高点估计的人群之间可能存在重叠。