Perspectum, Oxford, United Kingdom.
Centre for Inflammation Research, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
Front Endocrinol (Lausanne). 2021 Jan 27;11:575843. doi: 10.3389/fendo.2020.575843. eCollection 2020.
Late stage clinical trials in non-alcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH) are currently required by the FDA to use liver biopsy as a primary endpoint. The well-reported limitations with biopsy, such as associated risks and sampling error, coupled with patient preference, are driving investigation into non-invasive alternatives. MRI-derived biomarkers proton density fat fraction (PDFF) and iron-corrected T1 mapping (cT1) are gaining traction as emerging alternatives to biopsy for NASH. Our aim was to explore the correlations between cT1 and PDFF (from Liver®), with the histological components on the NAFLD-NASH spectrum in a large cohort of cross-sectional data, in order to calibrate the measurement to histology, and to infer what might constitute a clinically meaningful change when related to the FDA's criteria.
In a retrospective analysis of data combined from three previously published observational NASH studies, in which adult participants who underwent liver biopsy on suspicion of NAFLD or NASH and had an MRI scan measuring cT1 and PDFF (Liver®, Perspectum Ltd, UK), associations between imaging biomarkers and histology were tested using Spearman's rank correlation coefficient (r), and further exploration of the relationships between the imaging variables and histology were performed using linear regression.
N = 264 patients with mean age of 54 (SD:9.9), 39% female, and 69% with BMI ≥ 30kg.m were included in the analysis. cT1 and PDFF both correlated with all features of the NAFLD activity score (NAS). cT1 was also positively correlated with Kleiner-Brunt fibrosis. Partial correlations, adjusting for steatosis, revealed cT1 correlated with inflammation and fibrosis, whereas PDFF did not, and both were still associated with the NAS, but correlation was weaker with PDFF than cT1. An estimated difference of 88 ms in cT1, or 21% relative difference in PDFF was related to a two-point difference in overall NAS.
The correlations between cT1 and PDFF with the histopathological hallmarks of NASH demonstrate the potential utility of both cT1 and PDFF as non-invasive biomarkers to detect a pharmacodynamic change in NASH, with cT1 showing superiority for detecting changes in inflammation and fibrosis, rather than liver fat alone.
目前,FDA 要求非酒精性脂肪性肝炎(NASH)的晚期临床试验将肝活检作为主要终点。众所周知,活检存在相关风险和取样误差等局限性,再加上患者的偏好,促使人们对非侵入性替代方法进行研究。磁共振衍生的生物标志物质子密度脂肪分数(PDFF)和铁校正 T1 映射(cT1)作为 NASH 活检的替代方法正在逐渐得到认可。我们的目的是在一个大型横断面数据队列中,探索 cT1 和 PDFF(来自 Liver®)与 NAFLD-NASH 谱上的组织学成分之间的相关性,以便对测量值进行组织学校准,并推断与 FDA 标准相关时,什么可能构成有临床意义的变化。
在对以前发表的三项观察性 NASH 研究的数据进行回顾性分析中,对怀疑患有 NAFLD 或 NASH 而接受肝活检且进行了 MRI 扫描以测量 cT1 和 PDFF(Liver®,Perspectum Ltd,英国)的成年参与者进行了分析,使用 Spearman 秩相关系数(r)测试了影像学标志物与组织学之间的相关性,并使用线性回归进一步探索了影像学变量与组织学之间的关系。
共纳入 264 名患者,平均年龄为 54(SD:9.9)岁,39%为女性,69%的 BMI≥30kg·m²。cT1 和 PDFF 均与 NAFLD 活动评分(NAS)的所有特征相关。cT1 还与 Kleiner-Brunt 纤维化呈正相关。调整了脂肪变性后,部分相关性显示 cT1 与炎症和纤维化相关,而 PDFF 则没有,且两者仍与 NAS 相关,但与 cT1 相比,相关性较弱。cT1 估计相差 88ms,或 PDFF 相对差异 21%,与总体 NAS 相差两点有关。
cT1 和 PDFF 与 NASH 的组织病理学特征之间的相关性表明,cT1 和 PDFF 作为非侵入性生物标志物具有检测 NASH 药效变化的潜力,cT1 检测炎症和纤维化变化的优势优于单纯检测肝脂肪。