Smetana J G
Graduate School of Education and Human Development, University of Rochester, NY 14627.
Child Dev. 1988 Apr;59(2):321-35. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-8624.1988.tb01469.x.
This study assessed adolescents' and parents' conceptions of parental authority. Subjects were 102 children ranging from fifth to twelfth grade (age range = 10.2-18.3 years) from 2-parent families and their parents. They were divided into 4 groups according to children's grade level. Subjects were presented with 15 items pertaining to family transgressions (4 moral, 4 conventional, 3 personal, and 4 multifaceted, containing conventional and personal components). For each act, subjects were asked to judge the legitimacy of parental jurisdiction, justify its wrongness or permissibility, and assess its contingency on parental authority. As expected, all family members treated both moral and conventional issues as more legitimately subject to parental jurisdiction than multifaceted and personal issues. With increasing age of the adolescent, both parents and children became less likely to reason about the multifaceted and personal issues as conventional and sort them as contingent on parental authority; they became more likely to reason about and sort them as under the adolescents' personal jurisdiction. Adolescents at all ages, however, were more likely to reason about the multifaceted and personal issues as personal and sort them as under personal jurisdiction than were parents. Parents were more likely to reason conventionally and sort them as contingent on parental authority than were adolescents. These findings are discussed in terms of research on adolescent development, individuation, and social-cognitive development.
本研究评估了青少年和父母对父母权威的观念。研究对象是来自双亲家庭的102名五至十二年级的儿童(年龄范围 = 10.2 - 18.3岁)及其父母。根据儿童的年级水平,他们被分为4组。研究对象要面对15个与家庭违规行为相关的项目(4个道德方面的、4个常规方面的、3个个人方面的以及4个多方面的,包含常规和个人成分)。对于每一个行为,研究对象要判断父母管辖权的合法性,为其错误性或可允许性进行辩护,并评估其对父母权威的依赖性。正如预期的那样,与多方面和个人问题相比,所有家庭成员都认为父母对道德和常规问题拥有更合法的管辖权。随着青少年年龄的增长,父母和孩子都越来越不太可能将多方面和个人问题当作常规问题来推理,并将它们归类为依赖于父母权威;他们越来越倾向于将这些问题当作属于青少年个人管辖权范围内的问题来推理和归类。然而,在所有年龄段中,青少年比父母更有可能将多方面和个人问题当作个人问题来推理,并将它们归类为属于个人管辖权范围内的问题。与青少年相比,父母更倾向于按照常规方式推理,并将这些问题归类为依赖于父母权威。这些发现将依据青少年发展、个性化和社会认知发展方面的研究来进行讨论。