Ophthalmology, Byers Eye Institute, Stanford University School of Medicine, Palo Alto, California, United States; Ophthalmology, Taipei Medical University Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan; Computer Science and Information Engineering, National Taiwan University, Taipei, Taiwan.
Ophthalmology, Byers Eye Institute, Stanford University School of Medicine, Palo Alto, California, United States.
Int J Med Inform. 2021 Apr;148:104402. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2021.104402. Epub 2021 Jan 28.
Blepharoptosis is a known cause of reversible vision loss. Accurate assessment can be difficult, especially amongst non-specialists. Existing automated techniques disrupt clinical workflow by requiring user input, or placement of reference markers. Neural networks are known to be effective in image classification tasks. We aim to develop an algorithm that can accurately identify blepharoptosis from a clinical photo.
A total of 500 clinical photographs from patients with and without blepharoptosis were sourced from a tertiary ophthalmic center in Taiwan. Images were labeled by two oculoplastic surgeons, with an independent third oculoplastic surgeon to adjudicate disagreements. These images were used to train a series of convolutional neural networks (CNNs) to ascertain the best CNN architecture for this particular task.
Of the models that trained on the dataset, most were able to identify ptosis images with reasonable accuracy. We found the best performing model to use the DenseNet121 architecture without pre-training which achieved a sensitivity of 90.1 % with a specificity of 82.4 %, compared to the worst performing model which was used a Resnet34 architecture with pre-training, achieving a sensitivity of 74.1 %, and specificity of 63.6 %. Models with and without pre-training performed similarly (mean accuracy 82.6 % vs. 85.8 % respectively, p = 0.06), though models with pre-training took less time to train (1-minute vs. 16 min, p < 0.01).
We report the use of AI to accurately diagnose blepharoptosis from a clinical photograph with no external reference markers or user input requirement. Most current-generation CNN architectures performed reasonably on this task, with the DenseNet121, and Resnet18 architectures without pre-training performing best in our dataset.
上睑下垂是已知的可导致视力可逆性丧失的原因。对于非专业人员来说,准确评估可能较为困难。现有的自动化技术需要用户输入或放置参考标记,从而打断临床工作流程。神经网络在图像分类任务中表现出色。我们旨在开发一种能够从临床照片中准确识别上睑下垂的算法。
总共从台湾的一家三级眼科中心收集了 500 张患有和未患有上睑下垂的患者的临床照片。由两名眼整形外科医生对图像进行标记,并由独立的第三名眼整形外科医生来裁决分歧。使用这些图像来训练一系列卷积神经网络(CNN),以确定最适合该特定任务的 CNN 架构。
在所训练的模型中,大多数模型都能够以合理的准确度识别上睑下垂图像。我们发现表现最好的模型是使用 DenseNet121 架构而无需预训练,其敏感性为 90.1%,特异性为 82.4%,而表现最差的模型是使用 Resnet34 架构并进行了预训练,敏感性为 74.1%,特异性为 63.6%。具有和不具有预训练的模型表现相似(平均准确率分别为 82.6%和 85.8%,p = 0.06),尽管具有预训练的模型的训练时间更短(1 分钟与 16 分钟,p <0.01)。
我们报告了使用人工智能从临床照片中准确诊断上睑下垂的方法,无需外部参考标记或用户输入要求。大多数当前代的 CNN 架构在这项任务上表现良好,在我们的数据集中文献中,DenseNet121 和 Resnet18 架构无需预训练的表现最佳。