SELMET, INRAE, Montpellier SupAgro, CIRAD, Université Montpellier, 34000 Montpellier, France.
SELMET, INRAE, Montpellier SupAgro, CIRAD, Université Montpellier, 34000 Montpellier, France.
J Dairy Sci. 2021 May;104(5):5675-5688. doi: 10.3168/jds.2020-19075. Epub 2021 Mar 2.
Monitoring liveweight (LW) is an important part of sound management practices at the individual and flock level (e.g., controlling for nutritional status based on body condition, reproduction, and health-related issues), but it is time consuming and stressful. To our knowledge, no literature has reported on the evaluation of automated weighing systems in dairy sheep as an alternative to conventional static scales. The objective of this research was to evaluate the practical feasibility of using an automated walk-over-weighing (WoW) prototype to measure daily LW changes in dairy ewes without human intervention. We used adult Lacaune dairy ewes in 2 complementary trials conducted indoors. Trial 1 aimed at evaluating the repeatability, precision, and accuracy of LW measures recorded using WoW scales compared with a static scale (the gold standard). Forty-two adult ewes (LW ± standard deviation = 71.3 ± 10.4 kg) were randomly drafted from the main flock and used in a 1-day session. The trial included 3 passages. In each passage, ewes were weighed first on a static scale; once a static position was achieved and LW recorded, they continued the circuit and immediately traversed the WoW scale for an automated LW record. Trial 2 aimed to demonstrate the feasibility of using the WoW device under real-world conditions in a dairy sheep-farming system. The WoW scale was installed in the exit race of the milking parlor and evaluated over 7 wk with adult ewes in mid lactation (n = 93; LW 78.5 ± 8.1 kg). Once the ewes were acclimated to the WoW system, 1 group of ewes (n = 48) continued to receive the same feeding regimen (controls), and the other group (n = 45) underwent a nutritional challenge [challenged; 2 wk of undernutrition and then back to control regimen (refeeding) for 1 wk]. We evaluated the ability of the WoW to detect small changes in LW. We collected LW data (2 weighings per ewe per day) from the WoW after each of the 2 milking sessions (morning and evening). We also obtained LW values by weighing the ewes using a static scale once a week. The automated WoW system showed substantial agreement with the gold standard when assessed using Lin's concordance correlation coefficient and Bland and Altman's method, largely due to high repeatability. The WoW system was adequate for detecting small daily variations in LW during undernutrition and refeeding periods. Misbehaviors resulted in spurious WoW values in trial 2, requiring us to use filtration methods to exclude outlier weights and allow meaningful assessment of small LW changes. The WoW system evaluated here is an alternative to the static scales conventionally used on dairy sheep farms. If sound filtration of raw data is applied, WoW could contribute to the close (daily) monitoring of individual LW without operator intervention (i.e., voluntary weighing) and taking animal welfare into account (i.e., no stress related to the weighing session on static scales).
实时体重监测是个体和羊群层面上合理管理措施的重要组成部分(例如,根据身体状况、繁殖和健康相关问题来控制营养状况),但这既耗时又有压力。据我们所知,目前尚无文献报道过在奶绵羊中评估自动化称重系统作为传统静态秤的替代方案。本研究的目的是评估使用自动化走过称重(Walk-over-Weighting,WoW)原型来测量奶绵羊日常实时体重变化的实际可行性,而无需人工干预。我们在室内进行了两项互补性试验,使用成年拉卡奴奶绵羊。试验 1 旨在评估与静态秤(金标准)相比,WoW 秤记录实时体重的重复性、精度和准确性。42 只成年绵羊(实时体重±标准差=71.3±10.4kg)从主羊群中随机挑选出来,并在 1 天的试验中使用。该试验包括 3 个通道。在每个通道中,绵羊首先在静态秤上称重;一旦达到静态位置并记录实时体重,它们就会继续通过电路并立即走过 WoW 秤以自动记录实时体重。试验 2 旨在演示在奶绵羊养殖系统的实际条件下使用 WoW 设备的可行性。WoW 秤安装在挤奶厅的出口赛道上,并在泌乳中期的 93 只成年绵羊(实时体重 78.5±8.1kg)上进行了 7 周的评估。一旦绵羊适应了 WoW 系统,一组绵羊(n=48)继续接受相同的饲养方案(对照组),而另一组绵羊(n=45)则接受了营养挑战[受挑战;2 周的营养不良,然后恢复对照组饲养方案(再喂养)1 周]。我们评估了 WoW 检测实时体重小变化的能力。我们在每次挤奶后(早晚各一次)从 WoW 收集每只绵羊的实时体重数据(每天 2 次)。我们还每周通过静态秤对绵羊称重来获得实时体重值。当使用林氏一致性相关系数和 Bland 和 Altman 方法进行评估时,自动化 WoW 系统与金标准具有很大的一致性,这主要是由于其高重复性。在营养不足和再喂养期间,WoW 系统足以检测实时体重的微小日常变化。在试验 2 中,不当行为导致 WoW 出现虚假值,这需要我们使用过滤方法排除异常体重值,从而可以对实时体重的微小变化进行有意义的评估。在这里评估的 WoW 系统是传统上在奶绵羊养殖场使用的静态秤的替代方案。如果对原始数据进行合理的过滤,那么 WoW 可以有助于在不干预操作员(即自愿称重)的情况下进行个体实时体重的密切(每日)监测,并考虑动物福利(即,不在静态秤称重时产生与称重相关的压力)。