Whalley Celina, Payne Karl, Domingo Enric, Blake Andrew, Richman Susan, Brooks Jill, Batis Nikolaos, Spruce Rachel, Mehanna Hisham, Nankivell Paul, Beggs Andrew D
Institute of Cancer & Genomic Sciences, University of Birmingham, Vincent Drive, Birmingham B15 2TT, UK.
Department of Oncology, Nuffield Department of Medicine, University of Oxford, Oxford OX3 7BN, UK.
Epigenomes. 2021 Feb 19;5(1):6. doi: 10.3390/epigenomes5010006.
Abnormal CpG methylation in cancer is ubiquitous and generally detected in tumour specimens using a variety of techniques at a resolution encompassing single CpG loci to genome wide coverage. Analysis of samples with very low DNA inputs, such as formalin fixed (FFPE) biopsy specimens from clinical trials or circulating tumour DNA is challenging at the genome-wide level because of lack of available input. We present the results of low input experiments into the Illumina Infinium HD methylation assay on FFPE specimens and ctDNA samples.
For all experiments, the Infinium HD assay for methylation was used. In total, forty-eight FFPE specimens were used at varying concentrations (lowest input 50 ng); eighteen blood derived specimens (lowest input 10 ng) and six matched ctDNA input (lowest input 10 ng)/fresh tumour specimens (lowest input 250 ng) were processed. Downstream analysis was performed in R/Bioconductor for quality control metrics and differential methylation analysis as well as copy number calls.
Correlation coefficients for CpG methylation were high at the probe level averaged R2 = 0.99 for blood derived samples and R2 > 0.96 for the FFPE samples. When matched ctDNA/fresh tumour samples were compared, R2 > 0.91 between the two. Results of differential methylation analysis did not vary significantly by DNA input in either the blood or FFPE groups. There were differences seen in the ctDNA group as compared to their paired tumour sample, possibly because of enrichment for tumour material without contaminating normal. Copy number variants observed in the tumour were generally also seen in the paired ctDNA sample with good concordance via DQ plot.
The Illumina Infinium HD methylation assay can robustly detect methylation across a range of sample types, including ctDNA, down to an input of 10 ng. It can also reliably detect oncogenic methylation changes and copy number variants in ctDNA. These findings demonstrate that these samples can now be accessed by methylation array technology, allowing analysis of these important sample types.
癌症中异常的CpG甲基化普遍存在,通常使用多种技术在肿瘤标本中进行检测,分辨率涵盖单个CpG位点到全基因组范围。由于可用输入量不足,在全基因组水平上分析DNA输入量非常低的样本具有挑战性,例如来自临床试验的福尔马林固定(FFPE)活检标本或循环肿瘤DNA。我们展示了对FFPE标本和ctDNA样本进行低输入量实验的结果,这些实验采用了Illumina Infinium HD甲基化检测方法。
对于所有实验,均使用Infinium HD甲基化检测方法。总共使用了48个不同浓度的FFPE标本(最低输入量50 ng);处理了18个血液来源标本(最低输入量10 ng)和6对匹配的ctDNA输入(最低输入量10 ng)/新鲜肿瘤标本(最低输入量250 ng)。在R/Bioconductor中进行下游分析,以进行质量控制指标、差异甲基化分析以及拷贝数检测。
对于血液来源样本,CpG甲基化的相关系数在探针水平较高,平均R2 = 0.99;对于FFPE样本,R2 > 0.96。当比较匹配的ctDNA/新鲜肿瘤样本时,两者之间的R2 > 0.91。在血液或FFPE组中,差异甲基化分析的结果在DNA输入量方面没有显著差异。与配对的肿瘤样本相比,ctDNA组存在差异,可能是由于肿瘤物质富集而未受正常物质污染。通过DQ图可以看出,在肿瘤中观察到的拷贝数变异通常在配对的ctDNA样本中也有良好的一致性。
Illumina Infinium HD甲基化检测方法能够可靠地检测一系列样本类型(包括ctDNA)中的甲基化,最低输入量可达10 ng。它还能够可靠地检测ctDNA中的致癌甲基化变化和拷贝数变异。这些发现表明,现在可以通过甲基化阵列技术对这些样本进行分析,从而能够对这些重要的样本类型进行分析。