Misra Supriya, Jackson Valerie W, Chong Jeanette, Choe Karen, Tay Charisse, Wong Jazmine, Yang Lawrence H
San Francisco State University, San Francisco, CA, USA.
University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Am J Community Psychol. 2021 Dec;68(3-4):486-512. doi: 10.1002/ajcp.12516. Epub 2021 Apr 3.
Stigma is integral to understanding mental health disparities among racial and ethnic minority groups in the United States. We conducted a systematic review to identify empirical studies on cultural aspects of mental illness stigma (public, structural, affiliative, self) among three racial and ethnic minority groups (Asian Americans, Black Americans, Latinx Americans) from 1990 to 2019, yielding 97 articles. In comparison studies (N = 25), racial and ethnic minority groups often expressed greater public and/or self-stigma than White American groups. In within-group studies (N = 65; Asian American, n = 21; Black American, n = 18; Latinx American; n = 26), which were primarily qualitative (73%), four major cultural themes emerged: 1) service barriers including access and quality (structural stigma); 2) family experiences including concealment for family's sake, fear of being a burden, and stigma extending to family (affiliative stigma); 3) lack of knowledge about mental illness and specific cultural beliefs (public stigma); and 4) negative emotional responses and coping (self-stigma). These findings confirmed stigma has both similar and unique cultural aspects across groups. Despite this, few studies tested stigma reduction interventions (N = 7). These cultural insights can inform contextual change at the health systems and community levels to reduce stigma, and empowerment at the interpersonal and individual levels to resist stigma.
耻辱感是理解美国种族和少数族裔群体心理健康差异的一个重要因素。我们进行了一项系统综述,以确定1990年至2019年间关于三个种族和少数族裔群体(亚裔美国人、非裔美国人、拉丁裔美国人)精神疾病耻辱感(公众、结构、亲属、自我)文化方面的实证研究,共筛选出97篇文章。在比较研究(N = 25)中,种族和少数族裔群体往往比美国白人群体表现出更强的公众和/或自我耻辱感。在群体内部研究(N = 65;亚裔美国人,n = 21;非裔美国人,n = 18;拉丁裔美国人,n = 26)中,这些研究主要是定性研究(73%),出现了四个主要文化主题:1)服务障碍,包括可及性和质量(结构耻辱感);2)家庭经历,包括为了家庭而隐瞒、害怕成为负担以及耻辱感延伸到家庭(亲属耻辱感);3)对精神疾病和特定文化信仰缺乏了解(公众耻辱感);以及4)负面情绪反应和应对方式(自我耻辱感)。这些发现证实耻辱感在不同群体中既有相似的文化方面,也有独特的文化方面。尽管如此,很少有研究测试减少耻辱感的干预措施(N = 7)。这些文化见解可为卫生系统和社区层面的情境变化提供信息,以减少耻辱感,并在人际和个人层面增强抵御耻辱感的能力。