Division of Internal Medicine, Department of Infectious Diseases, Center for Tropical Medicine and Travel Medicine, University Medical Center, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Training and Research Unit of Excellence (TRUE), School of Public Health and Family Medicine, College of Medicine, University of Malawi, Blantyre, Malawi.
Malar J. 2021 Apr 27;20(1):203. doi: 10.1186/s12936-021-03742-x.
To further reduce malaria burden, identification of areas with highest burden for targeted interventions needs to occur. Routine health information has the potential to indicate where and when clinical malaria occurs the most. Developing countries mostly use paper-based data systems however they are error-prone as they require manual aggregation, tallying and transferring of data. Piloting was done using electronic data capture (EDC) with a cheap and user friendly software in rural Malawian primary healthcare setting to improve the quality of health records.
Audit and feedback tools from the Joanna Briggs Institute (Practical Application of Clinical Evidence System and Getting Research into Practice) were used in four primary healthcare facilities. Using this approach, the best available evidence for a malaria information system (MIS) was identified. Baseline audit of the existing MIS was conducted in the facilities based on available best practice for MIS; this included ensuring data consistency and completeness in MIS by sampling 25 random records of malaria positive cases. Implementation of an adapted evidence-based EDC system using tablets on an OpenDataKit platform was done. An end line audit following implementation was then conducted. Users had interviews on experiences and challenges concerning EDC at the beginning and end of the survey.
The existing MIS was paper-based, occupied huge storage space, had some data losses due to torn out papers and were illegible in some facilities. The existing MIS did not have documentation of necessary parameters, such as malaria deaths and treatment within 14 days. Training manuals and modules were absent. One health centre solely had data completeness and consistency at 100% of the malaria-positive sampled records. Data completeness and consistency rose to 100% with readily available records containing information on recent malaria treatment. Interview findings at the end of the survey showed that EDC was acceptable among users and they agreed that the tablets and the OpenDataKit were easy to use, improved productivity and quality of care.
Improvement of data quality and use in the Malawian rural facilities was achieved through the introduction of EDC using OpenDataKit. Health workers in the facilities showed satisfaction with the use of EDC.
为了进一步降低疟疾负担,需要确定干预措施负担最重的地区。常规卫生信息有可能显示出疟疾最常发生的地点和时间。发展中国家大多使用纸质数据系统,但由于需要人工汇总、计数和传输数据,这些系统容易出错。在马拉维农村初级保健环境中,使用廉价且用户友好的电子数据采集(EDC)软件对电子数据采集进行了试点,以提高卫生记录的质量。
乔安娜·布里格斯研究所(实用临床证据系统和将研究转化为实践)的审核和反馈工具在四个初级保健设施中使用。通过这种方法,确定了疟疾信息系统(MIS)的最佳现有证据。根据 MIS 的最佳实践,对现有 MIS 进行了基线审核;这包括通过对 25 份疟疾阳性病例的随机记录进行抽样,确保 MIS 中的数据一致性和完整性。然后使用基于 OpenDataKit 平台的平板电脑实施经过改编的基于证据的 EDC 系统。实施后进行了最终审核。在调查开始和结束时,用户对 EDC 的经验和挑战进行了访谈。
现有的 MIS 是纸质的,占用了大量存储空间,由于撕毁的文件而导致一些数据丢失,并且在一些设施中难以辨认。现有的 MIS 没有记录必要参数的文件,例如疟疾死亡和 14 天内的治疗。培训手册和模块也不存在。只有一个卫生中心在疟疾阳性抽样记录的 100%上具有数据完整性和一致性。数据完整性和一致性提高到 100%,因为可以方便地获得最近疟疾治疗信息的记录。调查结束时的访谈结果表明,EDC 在用户中是可以接受的,他们同意平板电脑和 OpenDataKit 易于使用,提高了生产力和护理质量。
通过引入使用 OpenDataKit 的 EDC,实现了马拉维农村设施中数据质量和使用的提高。设施中的卫生工作者对 EDC 的使用表示满意。