Ngo F Q, Blakely E A, Tobias C A, Chang P Y, Lommel L
Division of Biology and Medicine, University of California, Berkeley 94720.
Radiat Res. 1988 Jul;115(1):54-69.
The synergistic effects of low- and high-LET radiations were further studied with partially synchronized Chinese hamster V79 cells. Principally, nearly monoenergetic 425 MeV/u neon ions and 570 MeV/u argon ions produced near the Bragg peak were employed as the high-LET radiations and 225 kVp X rays as the low-LET counterpart. It was found that the killing effect due to damage interaction after sequential irradiations with the particle beam and X rays varies throughout the cell cycle. The greatest effect was observed in late-S phase which was most resistant to either of the radiations. The effect was quantitatively less in the G1/S border and in G2. Effects on pure mitotic cells have not been investigated in this study. For all cell stages studied, a dose of high-LET particles modified the shape of the X-ray survival curve in a way similar to the modification predicted by an appropriately selected X-ray dose. This finding suggests that the mechanism for the synergistic effects is similar to that operating for sequential treatments with X rays alone. Experiments with an S population, either incubated at 37 degrees C or room temperature between fractionation of high- and low-LET radiation treatments further verified that the damage involved is a repairable type. At a certain fractionation interval (6 to 8 h) following a dose of high-LET treatment, initially asynchronous cells were found to be very sensitive to X-irradiation. It is noteworthy that the net killing measured at this "radiosensitive window" was as effective as the killing observed by "immediately" sequential treatments with the same doses of high- and low-LET radiations. Such a time window also existed when the order of the treatment sequence was reversed except that the time of occurrence was earlier and the window was broader. This sensitization effect may be explained by radiation-induced G2 arrest together with an increase of radiosensitivity as the previously irradiated cells progress into S phase. Radiotherapy strategies using combined high-LET and low-LET radiations for rapidly proliferative tumors are presented.
利用部分同步化的中国仓鼠V79细胞进一步研究了低传能线密度(LET)和高LET辐射的协同效应。主要地,将在布拉格峰附近产生的能量近单能的425 MeV/u氖离子和570 MeV/u氩离子用作高LET辐射,而将225 kVp X射线用作低LET辐射。结果发现,在用粒子束和X射线进行顺序照射后,由于损伤相互作用导致的杀伤效应在整个细胞周期中有所不同。在对两种辐射最具抗性的S期后期观察到最大效应。在G1/S边界和G2期,效应在数量上较小。本研究未对纯有丝分裂细胞的效应进行研究。对于所研究的所有细胞阶段,高LET粒子剂量以类似于适当选择的X射线剂量所预测的方式改变了X射线存活曲线的形状。这一发现表明,协同效应的机制类似于单独用X射线进行顺序治疗时的机制。在高LET和低LET辐射分次治疗之间,将S期群体在37℃或室温下孵育的实验进一步证实,所涉及的损伤是可修复类型。在高LET治疗剂量后的某个分次间隔(6至8小时),发现最初不同步的细胞对X射线照射非常敏感。值得注意的是,在这个“放射敏感窗口”测得的净杀伤效果与用相同剂量的高LET和低LET辐射“立即”进行顺序治疗所观察到的杀伤效果一样有效。当治疗顺序颠倒时,也存在这样一个时间窗口,只是出现的时间更早且窗口更宽。这种敏化效应可以通过辐射诱导的G2期阻滞以及随着先前照射的细胞进入S期放射敏感性增加来解释。本文还提出了针对快速增殖肿瘤使用高LET和低LET辐射联合治疗的放疗策略。