Department of Radiotherapy and Radiation Oncology, Saarland University Medical Center, Homburg/Saar, Germany.
Department of Radiotherapy and Radiation Oncology, Saarland University Medical Center, Homburg/Saar, Germany.
Z Med Phys. 2022 May;32(2):149-158. doi: 10.1016/j.zemedi.2021.03.004. Epub 2021 May 7.
Glioblastoma (GBM) is one of the most common primary brain tumours in adults, with a dismal prognosis despite aggressive multimodality treatment by a combination of surgery and adjuvant radiochemotherapy. A detailed knowledge of the spreading of glioma cells in the brain might allow for more targeted escalated radiotherapy, aiming to reduce locoregional relapse. Recent years have seen the development of a large variety of mathematical modelling approaches to predict glioma migration. The aim of this study is hence to evaluate the clinical applicability of a detailed micro- and meso-scale mathematical model in radiotherapy. First and foremost, a clinical workflow is established, in which the tumour is automatically segmented as input data and then followed in time mathematically based on the diffusion tensor imaging data. The influence of several free model parameters is individually evaluated, then the full model is retrospectively validated for a collective of 3 GBM patients treated at our institution by varying the most important model parameters to achieve optimum agreement with the tumour development during follow-up. Agreement of the model predictions with the real tumour growth as defined by manual contouring based on the follow-up MRI images is analyzed using the dice coefficient. The tumour evolution over 103-212 days follow-up could be predicted by the model with a dice coefficient better than 60% for all three patients. In all cases, the final tumour volume was overestimated by the model by a factor between 1.05 and 1.47. To evaluate the quality of the agreement between the model predictions and the ground truth, we must keep in mind that our gold standard relies on a single observer's (CB) manually-delineated tumour contours. We therefore decided to add a short validation of the stability and reliability of these contours by an inter-observer analysis including three other experienced radiation oncologists from our department. In total, a dice coefficient between 63% and 89% is achieved between the four different observers. Compared with this value, the model predictions (62-66%) perform reasonably well, given the fact that these tumour volumes were created based on the pre-operative segmentation and DTI.
胶质母细胞瘤(GBM)是成年人中最常见的原发性脑肿瘤之一,尽管通过手术和辅助放化疗联合进行了积极的多模式治疗,但预后仍然不佳。详细了解胶质瘤细胞在大脑中的扩散情况,可能有助于进行更有针对性的强化放疗,以减少局部区域复发。近年来,已经开发出多种数学建模方法来预测胶质瘤的迁移。因此,本研究旨在评估详细的微观和介观数学模型在放疗中的临床适用性。首先,建立了一个临床工作流程,其中肿瘤作为输入数据自动进行分割,然后根据扩散张量成像数据进行时间上的数学跟踪。单独评估了几个自由模型参数的影响,然后通过改变最重要的模型参数,对我们机构治疗的 3 名 GBM 患者进行了回顾性验证,以实现与随访期间肿瘤发展的最佳一致性。通过基于随访 MRI 图像的手动轮廓定义,使用 Dice 系数分析模型预测与真实肿瘤生长的一致性。对于所有三个患者,模型可以预测 103-212 天的随访期间的肿瘤演变,其 Dice 系数均大于 60%。在所有情况下,模型最终都会高估肿瘤体积,其倍数为 1.05 到 1.47 之间。为了评估模型预测与真实肿瘤生长之间的一致性的质量,我们必须记住,我们的金标准依赖于一位观察者(CB)的手动勾画肿瘤轮廓。因此,我们决定通过包括我们科室的另外三位经验丰富的放射肿瘤学家在内的观察者间分析,对这些轮廓的稳定性和可靠性进行简短的验证。总的来说,四个不同观察者之间的 Dice 系数在 63%到 89%之间。与这个值相比,模型预测(62-66%)的表现相当不错,考虑到这些肿瘤体积是基于术前分割和 DTI 创建的。