Faculty of Architecture and Town Planning, 26747Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel.
Cambridge Digital Innovation-CJBS & Hughes Hall, University of Cambridge, United Kingdom.
HERD. 2021 Oct;14(4):114-129. doi: 10.1177/19375867211007945. Epub 2021 May 28.
The study examines the integration of the Evidence-based Design (EBD) approach in healthcare architecture education in the context of an academic design studio.
Previous research addressed the gap between scientific research and architectural practice and the lack of research on the use of the EBD approach in architectural education.
The research examines an undergraduate architectural studio to design a Maggie's Centre for cancer care in Israel and evaluates the impact of the EBD approach on the design process and design outcomes. The research investigates the impact of the integration of three predesign tasks: (1) literature review of healing architecture research, (2) analysis and comparison of existing Maggie's Centres, and (3) analysis of the context of the design project.
The literature review of scientific research supported the conceptual design and development of the projects. The analysis of existing Maggie's centers, which demonstrated the interpretation of the evidence by different architects, developed the students' ability to evaluate EBD in practice critically, and the study of the projects' local context led the students to define the relevance of the evidence to support their vision for the project.
The research demonstrates the advantages of practicing EBD at an early stage in healthcare architectural education to enhance awareness of the impact of architectural design on the users' health and well-being and the potential to support creativity and innovative design. More studies in design studios are needed to assess the full impact of integrating EBD in architectural education.
本研究在学术设计工作室的背景下,考察了循证设计(EBD)方法在医疗保健建筑教育中的整合。
先前的研究解决了科学研究与建筑实践之间的差距以及缺乏关于 EBD 方法在建筑教育中应用的研究的问题。
本研究考察了一个本科建筑工作室,以设计以色列的玛吉癌症关怀中心,并评估了 EBD 方法对设计过程和设计结果的影响。该研究调查了整合三个预先设计任务的影响:(1)对治疗建筑研究的文献综述,(2)对现有玛吉中心的分析和比较,以及(3)对设计项目背景的分析。
对科学研究的文献综述支持了项目的概念设计和开发。对现有玛吉中心的分析表明,不同建筑师对证据的解释,培养了学生对实践中 EBD 的批判性评估能力,对项目当地背景的研究促使学生确定证据与支持他们对项目的愿景的相关性。
本研究表明,在医疗保健建筑教育的早期阶段实践 EBD 的优势,提高了对建筑设计对使用者健康和福祉的影响的认识,以及支持创造力和创新设计的潜力。需要更多的设计工作室研究来评估在建筑教育中整合 EBD 的全部影响。