Institute of Cancer Research, London, UK.
Royal Marsden NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK.
Ir J Med Sci. 2022 Jun;191(3):1427-1434. doi: 10.1007/s11845-021-02637-9. Epub 2021 Jun 30.
As genomic profiling of constitutional and tumour-derived DNA becomes increasingly critical in cancer risk estimation, prognostication and treatment, there is a growing need for clinicians involved in cancer care to up-skill in Cancer Genetics. In the Republic of Ireland (ROI), this is particularly crucial, given a paucity of vocationally trained Clinical Geneticists per capita compared to other European countries.
We aimed to assess the self-reported confidence of postgraduate medical/surgical trainees in ROI in requesting, interpreting, and managing genomic data in patients with cancer, and to assess their selfreported experience, and demand for future training in this area.
A cross-sectional survey of postgraduate trainees in four specialties (Medical and Radiation Oncology, Surgery, and Obstetrics and Gynaecology (O&G)), training in ROI, was undertaken. A bespoke electronic questionnaire was designed to capture data regarding preceding experience, and confidence across several hypothetical clinical scenarios involving genomic testing. The survey was circulated to eligible participants by training programme administrators, after relevant institutional ethical approval. Data was collected anonymously.
The study cohort included 62 respondents. A paucity of cancer genetics training at every level was demonstrated, with "hardly any" or "none at all" reported by 47(76%), 62(100%), and 50(81%) during undergraduate, core specialty, and higher specialist training, respectively. A relative lack of confidence in all clinical scenarios was apparent, particularly among Surgery/O&G trainees. Most respondents would value more training in Cancer Genetics.
This study demonstrates an unmet need in dedicated Cancer Genetics training for postgraduate specialty trainees in ROI.
随着基因组分析在癌症风险评估、预后和治疗中的作用越来越重要,参与癌症治疗的临床医生越来越需要在癌症遗传学方面提高技能。在爱尔兰共和国(ROI),由于与其他欧洲国家相比,人均职业培训的临床遗传学家稀缺,因此这一点尤为重要。
我们旨在评估 ROI 研究生医学/外科受训者在请求、解释和管理癌症患者基因组数据方面的自我报告信心,并评估他们在这一领域的自我报告经验和对未来培训的需求。
对 ROI 培训的四个专业(医学和放射肿瘤学、外科和妇产科(O&G))的研究生受训者进行了横断面调查。专门设计了一份电子问卷,以获取涉及基因组测试的几个假设临床情景的先前经验和信心的数据。在获得相关机构伦理批准后,由培训计划管理员将调查分发给符合条件的参与者。数据是匿名收集的。
研究队列包括 62 名受访者。在各个层面都缺乏癌症遗传学培训,47(76%)、62(100%)和 50(81%)名受访者在本科、核心专业和高级专科培训中分别报告“几乎没有”或“完全没有”。在所有临床情景中,信心明显不足,尤其是外科/O&G 受训者。大多数受访者希望在癌症遗传学方面接受更多的培训。
这项研究表明,ROI 的研究生专业受训者在专门的癌症遗传学培训方面存在未满足的需求。