Martínez-Guzmán Antar, Johnson Katherine
Universidad de Colima, Mexico.
RMIT University, Australia.
Int J Transgend Health. 2020 May 19;22(3):253-268. doi: 10.1080/26895269.2020.1760164. eCollection 2021.
Mexico has the second-highest index of crimes motivated by transphobia in the world. Transphobic violence manifests in a pervasive and complex manner in a country where violence permeates all aspects of social life. Some progress has been made to improve transgender rights and fight discrimination, but this has had an unequal impact in different geopolitical and cultural contexts within the country, particularly outside of metropolitan centers.
The study explores how transphobia is experienced in the conservative province of Colima and how transphobic practices play a part in shaping transgender subjective experience and identity construction. A psychosocial theoretical framework is adopted to attend to the relationship between cultural, institutional and interpersonal practices in this process.
A qualitative approach is used to explore how different forms of transphobic violence are experienced by trans women in Colima. A purposive sample of 12 trans women, aged 22-38years took part in narrative interviews which were analyzed thematically. Findings: The analysis is organized into three themes: (a) narratives of gender identity construction (b) gender expression and experiences of transphobic violence in Colima (c) sites for social support and change.
We argue that the psychosocial processes related to transphobia are context-specific shaping transgender identities and limiting and regulating gender expression. Family, education, LGBT community and the police were identified as key sites for support against or source of transphobic violence.
Despite the challenging socio-political context interventions are needed in policy and institutional practices to tackle stigma, transphobia and, trans-misogyny and improve the lives of transgender people living in regional areas in the global south.
墨西哥是全球因恐跨症引发犯罪指数第二高的国家。在一个暴力渗透到社会生活方方面面的国家,恐跨暴力以一种普遍且复杂的方式表现出来。在改善跨性别者权利和打击歧视方面已取得一些进展,但在该国不同的地缘政治和文化背景下,尤其是在大都市中心以外地区,其影响并不均衡。
本研究探讨在保守的科利马省,人们如何体验恐跨症,以及恐跨行为如何在塑造跨性别者的主观体验和身份建构中发挥作用。采用社会心理理论框架来关注这一过程中文化、制度和人际行为之间的关系。
采用定性研究方法,探究科利马的跨性别女性如何体验不同形式的恐跨暴力。从12名年龄在22至38岁之间的跨性别女性中选取了一个有目的的样本,她们参与了叙事访谈,并对访谈内容进行了主题分析。
分析分为三个主题:(a)性别身份建构的叙事;(b)科利马的性别表达与恐跨暴力经历;(c)社会支持与变革的场所。
我们认为,与恐跨症相关的社会心理过程是因具体情境而异的,它塑造着跨性别者的身份,并限制和规范着性别表达。家庭、教育、 LGBT社群和警方被确定为反对恐跨暴力的关键支持场所或恐跨暴力的来源。
尽管社会政治背景具有挑战性,但仍需要在政策和制度实践中进行干预,以消除污名、恐跨症和跨性别女性厌女症,改善生活在全球南方偏远地区的跨性别者的生活。