Greenfield Brett, Alessi Edward J, Manning Dean, Dato Caroline, Dank Meredith
Social Work, Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey, New Brunswick, New Jersey, USA.
John Jay College of Criminal Justice, City University of New York, New York, New York, USA.
Int J Transgend Health. 2020 Nov 8;22(3):316-329. doi: 10.1080/26895269.2020.1838387. eCollection 2021.
Transgender and gender expansive (TGE) youth face a number of adversities that are associated with deleterious consequences, including mental health problems, substance misuse, suicide, and homelessness. However, there is evidence that TGE youth still demonstrate resilience under extraordinary conditions. Therefore, this study examined how TGE youth who are homeless and engaging in survival sex describe and understand the protective factors present in their lives. In-depth qualitative interviews were conducted with 57 TGE youth living in a large U.S. city. Participants were 17-26 years old (M = 19.88, SD = 1.55), and identified as transgender woman (53%), transgender man (16%), and other (32%; gender-queer, gender-fluid, androgynous, or non-binary). Youth identified as Black (40%), multiracial (35%), Latinx (16%), White (5%), and as another race (3%). Researchers conducted a secondary analysis of qualitative data using thematic analysis. We identified three themes to capture youth's understanding of their protective factors: relying on oneself and others to avoid violence, accessing gender-affirming health and mental health care, and proactively maintaining sexual health. Participants described strategies for mitigating risk of harm while attempting to meet their basic needs. Additionally, they discussed the importance of having gender-affirming health and mental health services. Participants also expressed keen awareness of their sexual health risks and making calculated, often proactive decisions about their sexual health. The protective factors described by TGE youth reflect the unique ways in which hyper-marginalized youth must navigate their own survival and well-being, and align with literature suggesting resilience is not mutually exclusive from risk. By focusing on TGE youth, this research privileges the experiences of individuals historically underrepresented in research and encourages future research to incorporate these perspectives into policies and programs.
跨性别及性别认同扩展(TGE)青年面临着许多会带来有害后果的逆境,包括心理健康问题、药物滥用、自杀和无家可归。然而,有证据表明,TGE青年在极端情况下仍表现出复原力。因此,本研究调查了无家可归且从事生存性交易的TGE青年如何描述和理解他们生活中存在的保护因素。对居住在美国一个大城市的57名TGE青年进行了深入的定性访谈。参与者年龄在17至26岁之间(M = 19.88,标准差 = 1.55),其中53%为跨性别女性,16%为跨性别男性,32%为其他性别(性别酷儿、性别流动者、雌雄同体者或非二元性别者)。青年中40%为黑人,35%为多种族,16%为拉丁裔,5%为白人,3%为其他种族。研究人员使用主题分析法对定性数据进行了二次分析。我们确定了三个主题来体现青年对其保护因素的理解:依靠自己和他人避免暴力、获得性别肯定的健康和心理健康护理、积极维护性健康。参与者描述了在试图满足基本需求时减轻伤害风险的策略。此外,他们讨论了获得性别肯定的健康和心理健康服务的重要性。参与者还表达了对自身性健康风险的敏锐认识,并对自己的性健康做出经过深思熟虑、通常是积极主动的决定。TGE青年所描述的保护因素反映了极度边缘化青年必须以独特方式应对自身生存和幸福的情况,这与表明复原力与风险并非相互排斥的文献一致。通过关注TGE青年,本研究重视了在研究中历史上代表性不足的个体的经历,并鼓励未来的研究将这些观点纳入政策和项目中。