Centre for Social Research and Methods, College of Arts & Social Sciences, Australian National University, RSSS Building, Canberra, 2601, Australia.
Population Health, Murdoch Children's Research Institute, Royal Children's Hospital, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
BMC Public Health. 2021 Jul 21;21(1):1434. doi: 10.1186/s12889-021-11469-2.
Racism and racial discrimination are fundamental causes and determinants of health and health inequalities globally, with children and adolescents particularly vulnerable. Racial discrimination is a common stressor in the lives of many children and adolescents, with growing evidence of negative associations between racial discrimination and multiple domains of child and adolescent health. Addressing racism and racial discrimination must be core public health priorities, even more so among children and young people. Schools are key settings in the lives of children and adolescents and become increasingly more important to identity formation. School communities, teachers and peers greatly influence children and adolescents' beliefs about race and difference. Schools are therefore key sites for the delivery of population-based programs to reduce racism and promote proactive bystander behaviour and healthy resistance to racism among all children and adolescents as well as among the adults.
This study examines the feasibility and acceptability of the 'Speak Out Against Racism (SOAR)' program, a whole of school, multi-level, multi-strategy program that aimed to promote effective bystander responses to racism and racial discrimination in primary schools. A mixed-methods, quasi-experimental design was used. Students in Years 5 and 6 (10-12 years) across six schools completed surveys pre- and post- intervention (N = 645; 52% female; 6% Indigenous, 10% Middle Eastern, African, Latinx or Pacific Islander, 21% Asian, 52% Anglo/European). Focus groups with students and interviews with staff collected qualitative data about their experiences of the program and their views about the program's perceived need, implementation, impacts and suggested improvements.
Quantitative data showed student prosocial skills and teacher inter-racial climate improved in intervention schools compared to comparison schools. Qualitative data highlighted teacher attitudinal and behaviour change regarding racism, and student reduced interpersonal racial discrimination, improved peer prosocial norms, commitment to anti-racism, knowledge of proactive bystander responses and confidence and self-efficacy to intervene to address racism.
This study provides quantitative evidence of the potential of the SOAR program to improve the prosocial skills of students and their perceptions of the inter-racial school climate provided by their teachers. This program also provided qualitative evidence of the potential to promote teacher and student attitudinal and behavioural change. Further refinement and testing of the program in a large scale implementation trial is recommended.
种族主义和种族歧视是全球健康和健康不平等的根本原因和决定因素,儿童和青少年尤其容易受到影响。种族歧视是许多儿童和青少年生活中的常见压力源,越来越多的证据表明,种族歧视与儿童和青少年健康的多个领域之间存在负面关联。解决种族主义和种族歧视必须是公共卫生的核心优先事项,尤其是在儿童和年轻人中。学校是儿童和青少年生活的重要场所,对于身份认同的形成变得越来越重要。学校社区、教师和同伴极大地影响着儿童和青少年对种族和差异的看法。因此,学校是实施基于人群的计划的关键场所,可以减少种族主义,促进所有儿童和青少年以及成年人中积极的旁观者行为和对种族主义的健康抵制。
本研究考察了“反对种族主义发声(SOAR)”计划的可行性和可接受性,这是一项针对小学的全校、多层次、多策略计划,旨在促进对种族主义和种族歧视的有效旁观者反应。采用混合方法、准实验设计。来自六所学校的五年级和六年级(10-12 岁)的学生在干预前后完成了调查(N=645;52%为女性;6%为土著,10%为中东、非洲、拉丁裔或太平洋岛民,21%为亚洲人,52%为盎格鲁/欧洲人)。与学生进行焦点小组讨论,并与工作人员进行访谈,收集关于他们对该计划的体验以及他们对该计划的感知需求、实施、影响和改进建议的看法的定性数据。
定量数据显示,与对照组学校相比,干预学校的学生亲社会技能和教师跨种族氛围有所改善。定性数据突出了教师在种族问题上的态度和行为变化,以及学生减少人际种族歧视、改善同伴亲社会规范、对反种族主义的承诺、对积极的旁观者反应的了解以及干预解决种族主义的信心和自我效能。
本研究提供了定量证据,表明 SOAR 计划有可能提高学生的亲社会技能和他们对教师提供的跨种族学校氛围的看法。该计划还提供了定性证据,表明有可能促进教师和学生的态度和行为改变。建议进一步改进和在大规模实施试验中测试该计划。