Department of Medicine, School of Medicine, College of Health Sciences, Makerere University, Kampala, Uganda.
Afya Bora Consortium.
Ann Glob Health. 2021 Jul 12;87(1):66. doi: 10.5334/aogh.3214. eCollection 2021.
Partnerships are essential to creating effective global health leadership training programs. Global pandemics, including the HIV/AIDS pandemic, and more recently the COVID-19 pandemic, have tested the impact and stability of healthcare systems. Partnerships must be fostered to prepare the next generation of leaders to collaborate effectively and improve health globally.
We provide key matrices that predict success of partnerships in building global health leadership capacity. We highlight opportunities and challenges to building effective partnerships and provide recommendations to promote development of equitable and mutually beneficial partnerships.
Critical elements for effective partnership when building global health leadership capacity include shared strategic vision, transparency and excellent communication, as well as intentional monitoring and evaluation of the partnership, not just the project or program. There must be recognition that partnerships can be unpredictable and unequal, especially if the end is not defined early on. Threats to equitable and effective partnerships include funding and co-funding disparities between partners from high-income and low-income countries, inequalities, unshared vision and priorities, skewed decision-making levels, and limited flexibility to minimize inequalities and make changes. Further, imbalances in power, privilege, position, income levels, and institutional resources create opportunities for exploitation of partners, particularly those in low-income countries, which widens the disparities and limits success and sustainability of partnerships. These challenges to effective partnering create the need for objective documentation of disparities at all stages, with key milestones to assess success and the environment to sustain the partnerships and their respective goals.
Developing effective and sustainable partnerships requires a commitment to equality from the start by all partners and an understanding that there will be challenges that could derail otherwise well-intended partnerships. Guidelines and training on evaluation of partnerships exist and should be used, including generic indicators of equity, mutual benefit, and the added value of partnering.
Effective partnerships in building global health leadership capacity require shared strategic vision and intentional monitoring and evaluation of goalsInequalities in partnerships may arise from disparities in infrastructure, managerial expertise, administrative and leadership capacity, as well as limited mutual benefit and mutual respectTo promote equitable and effective partnerships, it is critical to highlight and monitor key measures for success of partnerships at the beginning of each partnership and regularly through the lifetime of the partnership.We recommend that partnerships should have legal and financial laws through executed memoranda of understanding, to promote accountability and facilitate objective monitoring and evaluation of the partnership itself.More research is needed to understand better the contextual predictors of the broader influence and sustainability of partnership networks in global health leadership training.
伙伴关系对于创建有效的全球卫生领导力培训计划至关重要。全球大流行病,包括艾滋病毒/艾滋病大流行,以及最近的 COVID-19 大流行,都考验了医疗保健系统的影响力和稳定性。必须建立伙伴关系,为下一代领导者做好有效合作和改善全球健康的准备。
我们提供了预测伙伴关系在建立全球卫生领导力能力方面成功的关键矩阵。我们强调了建立有效伙伴关系的机会和挑战,并提出了促进公平和互利伙伴关系发展的建议。
建立全球卫生领导力能力的有效伙伴关系的关键要素包括共同的战略愿景、透明度和卓越的沟通,以及对伙伴关系的有意监测和评估,而不仅仅是项目或计划。必须认识到,伙伴关系可能是不可预测的和不平等的,特别是如果最终目标没有尽早确定。公平和有效的伙伴关系面临的威胁包括来自高收入和低收入国家的伙伴之间的资金和共同供资差距、不平等、缺乏共同的愿景和优先事项、决策级别不平衡以及缺乏灵活性以最大限度地减少不平等和进行变革。此外,权力、特权、地位、收入水平和机构资源方面的不平衡为合作伙伴创造了剥削机会,特别是在低收入国家的合作伙伴,这加剧了差距,并限制了伙伴关系的成功和可持续性。这些有效伙伴关系的挑战需要在各个阶段客观记录差异,确定关键里程碑以评估成功,并为伙伴关系及其各自目标创造维持环境。
从所有合作伙伴的平等承诺开始,开发有效和可持续的伙伴关系需要从一开始就承诺平等,并认识到可能会有破坏原本良好意图的伙伴关系的挑战。关于伙伴关系评估的准则和培训是存在的,应该加以利用,包括公平、互利和伙伴关系附加值的通用指标。
建立全球卫生领导力能力的有效伙伴关系需要共同的战略愿景和对目标的有意监测和评估;伙伴关系中的不平等可能源于基础设施、管理专业知识、行政和领导能力方面的差距,以及有限的互利和相互尊重;为了促进公平和有效的伙伴关系,关键是在每个伙伴关系开始时以及在伙伴关系的整个生命周期中定期突出和监测伙伴关系成功的关键措施;我们建议,伙伴关系应通过执行谅解备忘录制定法律和财务法律,以促进问责制并促进对伙伴关系本身的客观监测和评估;需要进一步研究,以更好地了解全球卫生领导力培训伙伴关系网络更广泛影响和可持续性的背景预测因素。