University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia.
Network of Alcohol and other Drugs Agencies, Woolloomooloo, NSW, Australia.
Health Soc Care Community. 2022 Jul;30(4):e1183-e1193. doi: 10.1111/hsc.13525. Epub 2021 Jul 30.
It is generally recognised that engaging consumers to participate in policy making, programming, and practice is fundamental to effective alcohol and other drug (AOD) treatment, however, literature continues to document challenges and barriers to its implementation in AOD settings. This study reports on an evaluation of the Consumer Participation Project implemented in key non-government AOD services in Australia. Data collection consisted of an online survey of 86 staff members at the five participating AOD services and 27 consumer interviews. The survey examined staff attitudes towards and beliefs about consumer participation, perceived current levels of consumer participation and service changes as a result of the consumer participation project. The qualitative arm explored consumer's prior knowledge and current experiences of consumer participation. Staff who took part in the consumer participation training offered as part of the project were more likely to believe that service changes could encourage greater consumer participation rather than any barriers associated with consumer circumstances. Additionally, while services offered low-level involvement consumer activities, there were fewer examples of mid- and high-level activities being conducted at the different services. Consumers discussed the significance of being actively involved in their AOD treatment service while stressing the importance of proper training and support for those engaging in consumer participation. This research highlights the benefits of consumer participation in AOD treatment and suggests that most consumer participation activities undertaken at present are "low" level involvement concerned with providing and receiving information from consumers. Importantly, however, our study did demonstrate some support for "high" level involvement activities and service providers being open to doing more to encourage consumer participation.
人们普遍认识到,让消费者参与政策制定、规划和实践是有效治疗酒精和其他药物(AOD)的基础,但文献仍在不断记录 AOD 环境中实施这一措施所面临的挑战和障碍。本研究报告了在澳大利亚主要的非政府 AOD 服务中实施消费者参与项目的评估结果。数据收集包括对五个参与 AOD 服务的 86 名工作人员进行的在线调查和对 27 名消费者的访谈。该调查考察了工作人员对消费者参与的态度和信念、对当前消费者参与水平和因消费者参与项目而导致的服务变化的看法。定性部分探讨了消费者对消费者参与的先前知识和当前经验。参与该项目提供的消费者参与培训的工作人员更有可能相信服务变化可以鼓励更多的消费者参与,而不是任何与消费者情况相关的障碍。此外,尽管服务提供了低水平的参与消费者活动,但在不同服务中进行中高级活动的例子较少。消费者讨论了积极参与他们的 AOD 治疗服务的重要性,同时强调了对参与消费者参与的人员进行适当培训和支持的重要性。这项研究强调了 AOD 治疗中消费者参与的好处,并表明目前开展的大多数消费者参与活动都是“低”水平的参与,涉及向消费者提供和接收信息。然而,重要的是,我们的研究确实表明了对“高”水平参与活动的一些支持,并且服务提供者愿意采取更多措施来鼓励消费者参与。