Veterans Affairs New Jersey Healthcare System, Lyons, New Jersey.
Corresponding author: Alejandro Interian, PhD, VA New Jersey Healthcare System, 151 Knollcroft Rd (116A), Lyons, NJ 07939 (
J Clin Psychiatry. 2021 Aug 31;82(5):20m13791. doi: 10.4088/JCP.20m13791.
This study evaluated whether Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy for Preventing Suicide Behavior (MBCT-S) effectively augmented treatment-as-usual enhanced for suicide prevention (eTAU). From December 2013 through March 2018, veterans (N = 140) at high risk for suicide were recruited mostly (88.6%) during a suicide-related inpatient admission and randomly assigned to either (1) eTAU augmented with MBCT-S or (2) eTAU only. MBCT-S began during inpatient treatment (2 individual sessions emphasizing safety planning) and continued post-discharge (8 group sessions emphasizing mindfulness skills and elaborated safety planning). Four follow-up evaluations occurred over 12 months, and primary outcomes were (1) time to suicide event and (2) number of suicide events. Secondary outcomes were time to and number of suicide attempts, proportion with acute psychiatric hospitalization, and change in suicide-related factors (eg, depression, hopelessness, suicidal ideation). Relative to eTAU, MBCT-S did not significantly delay time to suicide event (hazard ratio = 0.86; 95% CI, 0.52-1.41; = .54), but did reduce total number of suicide events (MBCT-S: 56 events; eTAU: 92 events; incident rate ratio = 0.59; 95% CI, 0.36-0.99; < .05). There were no significant differences in time to or number of suicide attempts. In a post hoc analysis, however, MBCT-S significantly reduced the proportion of participants attempting suicide ( < .05). MBCT-S also reduced the proportion with a psychiatric hospitalization. No significant between-group differences emerged on any suicide-related factors. Adding MBCT-S to system-wide suicide prevention efforts produced mixed findings on the primary outcome (suicide events) and promising findings on other important outcomes (suicide attempts, psychiatric hospitalizations). MBCT-S should continue to be examined in future research. ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT01872338.
本研究评估了正念认知疗法预防自杀行为(MBCT-S)是否有效增强了预防自杀的治疗增强(eTAU)。 从 2013 年 12 月至 2018 年 3 月,招募了高自杀风险的退伍军人(N=140),主要是在与自杀相关的住院治疗期间(88.6%),并随机分配到以下两组之一:(1)eTAU 增强与 MBCT-S 或(2)仅 eTAU。MBCT-S 在住院治疗期间开始(2 次个人会议强调安全计划),并在出院后继续进行(8 次小组会议强调正念技能和详细的安全计划)。在 12 个月内进行了 4 次随访评估,主要结局为(1)自杀事件发生时间和(2)自杀事件数量。次要结局是自杀企图的时间和数量、急性精神科住院的比例,以及与自杀相关的因素(例如,抑郁、绝望、自杀意念)的变化。 与 eTAU 相比,MBCT-S 并没有显著延迟自杀事件发生时间(危险比=0.86;95%CI,0.52-1.41; =0.54),但确实减少了自杀事件总数(MBCT-S:56 起事件;eTAU:92 起事件;发生率比=0.59;95%CI,0.36-0.99; <0.05)。自杀企图的时间或数量没有显著差异。然而,在事后分析中,MBCT-S 显著降低了试图自杀的参与者比例( <0.05)。MBCT-S 还降低了精神科住院的比例。在任何与自杀相关的因素上,两组之间均无显著差异。 在系统范围的预防自杀工作中增加 MBCT-S 对主要结局(自杀事件)的发现存在混合结果,对其他重要结局(自杀企图、精神科住院)的发现有希望。MBCT-S 应在未来的研究中继续进行检查。 临床试验.gov 标识符:NCT01872338。