Department of Dermatology, Rasool Akram Medical Complex, Iran University of Medical Sciences (IUMS), Tehran, Iran.
Student Research Committee, School of Medicine, Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
J Cosmet Dermatol. 2022 Jul;21(7):2727-2741. doi: 10.1111/jocd.14480. Epub 2021 Oct 4.
Alopecia areata (AA) in its extensive and severe forms is treatment-challenging, especially in pediatrics.
A PRISMA-compliant systematic review of seven electronic databases was searched by the terms "alopecia areata," "pediatric," "topical immunotherapy," "Anthralin," and "light therapy" from inception until March 2021. All the alternative names of the disease and therapies have been included in the search terms. 790 articles went to title abstract review by two independent reviewers. In the subsequent level, a review of the full text of studies was conducted.
Finally, 10 relevant articles in terms of content structure, subject coverage, and purpose, were selected for further review. The highest percentages of complete hair regrowth were 79.6% and 63.61% by SADBE (topical immunotherapy) and laser therapy. By Anthralin (contact sensitization), the complete response rate was below 50% (between 30 and 35%). Regarding average response, the most effective methods were local immunotherapy (with an average effectiveness of 53.8%), laser therapy (52.55%), and the use of Anthralin-induced contact dermatitis (30.86%), respectively. However, recurrence rate-after treatment with induced contact dermatitis by topical medications like Anthralin (contact sensitization)-was lower (mean 43.53%) in comparison with local immunotherapy (57%). In topical immunotherapy, light base therapy, and contact sensitization, the highest percentage of complete hair regrowth and the average response rate were (63.61% and 52.55%), (79.6% and 53.8%) and (32% and 30.8%), respectively. These methods are considered safe in children.
A high and more than 50% efficacy in hair regrowth could be expected by topical immunotherapy and light/laser therapy method. No serious side effects have been observed by these methods that are well tolerated in children. Therefore, a combination of local immunotherapy and light/laser therapy could be suggested for the treatment of extensive AA in children. The use of Anthralin could be associated with a lower but more durable response. These points are important for patient selection in individualized situations.
广泛性和严重性斑秃是一种具有挑战性的治疗疾病,尤其是在儿科领域。
通过在七个电子数据库中使用“斑秃”、“儿科”、“局部免疫疗法”、“蒽林”和“光疗”等术语进行符合 PRISMA 标准的系统综述,检索从成立到 2021 年 3 月的所有内容。疾病的所有替代名称和疗法均包含在检索词中。两名独立审查员对 790 篇文章进行了标题摘要审查。在随后的水平上,对研究的全文进行了审查。
最终,根据内容结构、主题覆盖范围和目的,选择了 10 篇相关文章进行进一步审查。SADBE(局部免疫疗法)和激光疗法的完全毛发再生率最高分别为 79.6%和 63.61%。蒽林(接触致敏)的完全反应率低于 50%(30%至 35%之间)。关于平均反应,最有效的方法是局部免疫疗法(有效率为 53.8%)、激光疗法(52.55%)和蒽林诱导的接触性皮炎的使用(30.86%)。然而,与局部免疫疗法(57%)相比,局部免疫疗法等局部药物诱导接触性皮炎(接触致敏)治疗后的复发率较低(平均 43.53%)。在局部免疫疗法、光基疗法和接触致敏中,完全毛发再生的最高百分比和平均反应率分别为(63.61%和 52.55%)、(79.6%和 53.8%)和(32%和 30.8%)。这些方法在儿童中被认为是安全的。
通过局部免疫疗法和光/激光疗法可以预期达到 50%以上的高毛发再生疗效。这些方法在儿童中耐受性良好,没有观察到严重的副作用。因此,对于儿童广泛性斑秃,可以建议采用局部免疫疗法联合光/激光疗法。蒽林的使用可能会导致反应率较低,但更持久。这些观点对于个体化情况下的患者选择很重要。