Department of Adult Health Nursing, Kamuzu College of Nursing, University of Malawi, Lilongwe, Malawi.
Department of Public Sector Management, Jubilee University, Lilongwe, Malawi.
PLoS One. 2021 Oct 15;16(10):e0257126. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0257126. eCollection 2021.
Female adolescents living with Human Immunodeficiency Virus are a unique population facing lifelong challenges in reproductive and sexual health ranging from relational, social and legal-ethical considerations. While HIV prevalence of young females is higher than the males (4.9% versus 1%), evidence show that these adolescents in Malawi initiate sex as early as 15 years mostly with adult partners. Yet, young people are frequently reported to be reluctant to discuss sexual matters and demonstrate avoidance of direct questions on sexual issues during interviews. It is critical therefore that researchers invoke youth-friendly approaches to address these complex issues and enable these vulnerable individuals to articulate and advocate for their preferred futures.
This study used an innovative visual qualitative approach known as 'my story' book which combined image selection and sentence completion exercises to enable adolescents living with HIV to share their stories through interviews. The study involved 14 cases comprising of 14 female adolescents aged 15 to 19, 14 caregivers and 14 health providers working at HIV multidisciplinary centres in Malawi.
The 'my story' book enabled in-depth exploration of the experiences and issues faced by this vulnerable population. The use of images and sentence completion exercise enabled the researcher to appreciate the type of interactions (or lack of) on sexual issues and status disclosure to significant others including sexual partners. Three themes were revealed, included creating meanings, revealing confirmatory and/or complementary evidence and enabling intergenerational research.
The 'my story' book captured the life experiences and needs of the female adolescents. The book assisted the participants in constructing, communicating, and controlling the articulation of their stories. It positioned female adolescents as a diverse group of social agents able to construct and reflect on their social worlds and real-life issues. This approach was highly effective in creating a youth-friendly context for reflection and revelation regarding sensitive cultural and social issues faced by this group. As such, the 'my story' book could be used in one-on-one counselling or provide data to inform intervention development.
感染人类免疫缺陷病毒的女性青少年是一个独特的群体,她们在生殖和性健康方面面临着终身挑战,包括关系、社会和法律伦理方面的考虑。尽管年轻女性的 HIV 感染率高于男性(4.9%对 1%),但有证据表明,马拉维的这些青少年早在 15 岁就开始与成年伴侣发生性行为。然而,年轻人经常被报道不愿意讨论性问题,并在采访中回避直接询问性问题。因此,研究人员必须采用对年轻人友好的方法来解决这些复杂的问题,使这些弱势群体能够表达自己的意见,并为自己的未来主张。
本研究采用了一种创新的视觉定性方法,称为“我的故事”书,它结合了图像选择和句子完成练习,使感染艾滋病毒的青少年能够通过访谈分享他们的故事。该研究涉及 14 例,包括 14 名 15 至 19 岁的女性青少年、14 名照顾者和 14 名在马拉维艾滋病毒多学科中心工作的卫生工作者。
“我的故事”书使我们能够深入探讨这个弱势群体的经历和面临的问题。使用图像和句子完成练习使研究人员能够了解他们在性问题和向重要他人(包括性伴侣)披露性状况方面的互动类型(或缺乏)。揭示了三个主题,包括创造意义、揭示证实性和/或互补证据以及实现代际研究。
“我的故事”书捕捉了女性青少年的生活经历和需求。这本书帮助参与者构建、交流和控制他们故事的表达。它将女性青少年定位为一群多样化的社会代理人,能够构建和反思他们的社会世界和现实生活中的问题。这种方法在为这一群体面临的敏感文化和社会问题创造一个对年轻人友好的反思和启示的背景方面非常有效。因此,“我的故事”书可以用于一对一咨询,也可以提供数据来为干预措施的制定提供信息。