Videira-Silva António, Hetherington-Rauth Megan, Sardinha Luís B, Fonseca Helena
Faculty of Medicine, Pediatric University Clinic, University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal.
Faculty of Human Kinetics, Exercise and Health Laboratory, University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal.
Eur J Sport Sci. 2023 Jan;23(1):109-120. doi: 10.1080/17461391.2021.1995508. Epub 2021 Nov 12.
Effective and safe exercise protocols for obesity management in adolescents are imperative. This study aimed to analyse compliance, efficacy, and safety of combined high-intensity interval training circuit (HIIT) in the management of obesity (including overweight) in adolescents, compared to traditional training (TT). Data from 55 adolescents (47.3% girls) (TT = 31; HIIT = 24), aged 12-18 (mean age of 14.3 ± 1.7), with overweight and obesity (median BMI z-score of 2.95), were assessed at baseline and month 6 (Clinicaltrials.gov/NCT02941770). During the 6-month intervention, participants in both exercise groups attended two exercise sessions/week (60 min/session) along with a set of appointments with a paediatrician, nutritionist, and exercise physiologist. Forty-six participants completed the intervention (TT = 23; HIIT = 23). Exercise session attendance (≥80%) was significantly higher among HIIT participants (73.9 vs. 13.0%, < .001). HIIT, but not TT, showed a significant decrease in BMI z-score (= 0.40, < .001), body fat mass (BFM, %) (= 0.41, = .001), and trunk fat mass (= 0.56, < .001), as well as a significant increase in muscle mass (MM, %) (= 0.28, = .001) between baseline and 6 months. According to generalized estimating equations, time-by-attendance interactions (instead of time-by group) were found in BMI z-score (= 0.25, 95%CI: 0.17, 0.33), BFM (= 2.29, 95%CI: 1.02, 3.56), trunk fat mass (= 2.94, 95%CI: 1.70, 4.18), and MM (= -1.16, 95%CI: -1.87, -0.45). No adverse events were reported during HIIT sessions. Although compliance may mediate the impact of an exercise protocol on health-related outcomes, HIIT showed to be safe, with higher compliance compared to TT, which may result in improved outcomes overtime.
制定有效且安全的青少年肥胖管理运动方案势在必行。本研究旨在分析与传统训练(TT)相比,联合高强度间歇训练循环(HIIT)在青少年肥胖(包括超重)管理中的依从性、有效性和安全性。对55名年龄在12 - 18岁(平均年龄14.3±1.7岁)、患有超重和肥胖(BMI z评分中位数为2.95)的青少年(47.3%为女孩)(TT组 = 31人;HIIT组 = 24人)在基线和第6个月时进行了评估(Clinicaltrials.gov/NCT02941770)。在为期6个月的干预期间,两个运动组的参与者每周参加两次运动课程(每次60分钟),同时还与儿科医生、营养师和运动生理学家进行了一系列预约。46名参与者完成了干预(TT组 = 23人;HIIT组 = 23人)。HIIT组参与者的运动课程出勤率(≥80%)显著更高(73.9%对13.0%,P <.001)。与基线相比,HIIT组(而非TT组)的BMI z评分(P = 0.40,P <.001)、体脂质量(BFM,%)(P = 0.41,P =.001)和躯干脂肪质量(P = 0.56,P <.001)显著降低,肌肉质量(MM,%)显著增加(P = 0.28,P =.001)。根据广义估计方程,在BMI z评分(P = 0.25,95%CI:0.17,0.33)、BFM(P = 2.29,95%CI:1.02,3.56)、躯干脂肪质量(P = 2.94,95%CI:1.70,4.18)和MM(P = -1.16,95%CI:-1.87,-0.45)方面发现了出勤时间交互作用(而非时间分组交互作用)。HIIT课程期间未报告不良事件。尽管依从性可能会介导运动方案对健康相关结果的影响,但HIIT显示是安全的,与TT相比依从性更高,这可能会随着时间推移带来更好的结果。