State Key Laboratory of Lake Science and Environment, Nanjing Institute of Geography and Limnology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Nanjing 210008, China.
State Key Laboratory of Lake Science and Environment, Nanjing Institute of Geography and Limnology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Nanjing 210008, China; Graduate University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China.
J Environ Manage. 2022 Jan 15;302(Pt A):113892. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2021.113892. Epub 2021 Oct 20.
The classical lake internal phosphorus (P) pollution control using P-inactivating materials is typically carried out by reducing the release of soluble P from sediments to overlying water; however, particulate P loading through sediment resuspension could also cause internal P pollution for algae breeding. Therefore, based on lanthanum modified bentonite clay (Phoslock®) and drinking water treatment residues (DWTR), the effect of P inactivating materials on sediment resuspension and settlement were comprehensively investigated to assess the variations in particulate P pollution from sediment. Results showed that both materials could effectively control soluble P pollution from sediment, while both had limited effect on the supplement of particulate P to overlying water. The reason may be that hydrodynamic disturbance was the key factor regulating sediment resuspension and settlement. The disturbance induced the resuspension of different sized sediments, especially <8 μm fractions, while increasing disturbing intensities promoted resuspension of relatively larger sized sediments (e.g., <63 μm). Further analysis suggested that after resuspension and settlement, the efficiencies of reducing bioavailable P by Phoslock® in relatively large sized sediment fraction (e.g., <63 μm) were substantially less than those in relatively small sized sediment (<8 μm). Although the reducing efficacies of DWTR had limited changes in different sized sediments, the remaining bioavailable P were clearly higher in smaller sized sediments with DWTR. The different performances on bioavailable P reduction mainly resulted from the distributions of materials and original P in different sized sediments. These findings indicated the potential supplement of particulate P for algal growth during resuspension and settlement of sediments amended by P inactivating materials. Overall, understanding the sediment P bioavailability and hydraulic properties at different sizes and the lake hydrodynamic conditions is essential to develop appropriate methods to control lake internal P pollution.
采用钝化材料控制湖泊内源磷(P)污染通常是通过减少沉积物中可溶性 P 向水体上层的释放来实现的;然而,通过沉积物再悬浮引起的颗粒 P 负荷也可能导致藻类繁殖的内源 P 污染。因此,本研究基于镧改性膨润土粘土(Phoslock®)和饮用水处理残渣(DWTR),综合考察了钝化材料对沉积物再悬浮和沉降的影响,以评估沉积物中颗粒 P 污染的变化。结果表明,两种材料均可有效控制沉积物中可溶性 P 的污染,但对补充颗粒 P 到水体上层的作用有限。其原因可能是水动力扰动是调节沉积物再悬浮和沉降的关键因素。扰动诱导不同粒径沉积物的再悬浮,特别是 <8 μm 粒径的沉积物,而增加扰动强度则促进相对较大粒径沉积物(如 <63 μm)的再悬浮。进一步分析表明,再悬浮和沉降后,Phoslock®在相对较大粒径沉积物(如 <63 μm)中降低生物有效 P 的效率明显低于相对较小粒径沉积物(如 <8 μm)。尽管 DWTR 在不同粒径沉积物中的降低效率变化不大,但 DWTR 在较小粒径沉积物中残留的生物有效 P 明显更高。生物有效 P 降低效率的差异主要是由于材料和原始 P 在不同粒径沉积物中的分布不同所致。这些发现表明,在受钝化材料处理的沉积物再悬浮和沉降过程中,颗粒 P 可能会为藻类生长提供补充。总之,了解不同粒径沉积物的磷生物有效性和水力特性以及湖泊水动力条件对于开发控制湖泊内源 P 污染的适当方法至关重要。