Divisions of Adolescent Medicine
Pediatric Critical Care, Department of Pediatrics, Indiana University School of Medicine, Indianapolis, Indiana.
Pediatrics. 2021 Nov;148(5). doi: 10.1542/peds.2021-050220. Epub 2021 Oct 28.
Adolescents and young adults living with intellectual disability (ID) have made significant advancements integrating into multiple aspects of western society, but there has been less progress with regards to sexual health. While advocating for individuals with ID to live life to the fullest, pediatricians have practical concerns regarding the ability to consent to sex as well as avoid coercion and manipulation in sexual encounters. This has led to tension between supporting the autonomy of a patient with ID while protecting them from harm. We present a case of a young adult with moderate ID who is engaging in a sexual relationship with her boyfriend without parental knowledge. The pediatrician must decide the most appropriate course of action to support the patient's autonomy but also ensure that the patient is a willing participant and understands the risks of engaging in sexual activity. This case highlights 4 main themes: (1) practical concerns when approaching sexual health in the adolescent with ID, (2) advocating for the rights of those with ID to live life to the fullest, (3) the critical inclusion of individuals with ID in decisions directly affecting them and their peer group, and (4) decision-making capacity and respect for autonomy in individuals with ID. This case highlights the delicate balance providers face when providing care to adolescents and young adults with ID: supporting autonomy to make decisions while reducing harm to a vulnerable population.
青少年和青年智障人士(ID)在融入西方社会的多个方面取得了重大进展,但在性健康方面进展较少。儿科医生一方面倡导 ID 人士充分享受生活,另一方面又对其同意性行为的能力以及避免性接触中的强迫和操纵表示担忧。这导致在支持 ID 患者的自主权和保护他们免受伤害之间产生了紧张关系。我们提出了一个案例,一名患有中度 ID 的年轻女性在没有父母知情的情况下与她的男朋友发生性关系。儿科医生必须决定最适当的行动方案,以支持患者的自主权,但也要确保患者是自愿参与并了解参与性活动的风险。该案例突出了 4 个主要主题:(1)在 ID 青少年中处理性健康问题时的实际关注点,(2)倡导 ID 人士充分享受生活的权利,(3)直接影响 ID 人士及其同龄群体的决策中至关重要的包容性,以及(4)ID 人士的决策能力和自主权的尊重。该案例突出了提供者在为 ID 青少年和年轻人提供护理时面临的微妙平衡:支持自主决策,同时减少对弱势群体的伤害。