Programme in Health Services and Systems Research, Duke-NUS Medical School, Singapore, Singapore; Centre for Quantitative Medicine, Duke-NUS Medical School, Singapore, Singapore.
Centre for Quantitative Medicine, Duke-NUS Medical School, Singapore, Singapore.
J Biomed Inform. 2022 Jan;125:103959. doi: 10.1016/j.jbi.2021.103959. Epub 2021 Nov 23.
Scoring systems are highly interpretable and widely used to evaluate time-to-event outcomes in healthcare research. However, existing time-to-event scores are predominantly created ad-hoc using a few manually selected variables based on clinician's knowledge, suggesting an unmet need for a robust and efficient generic score-generating method.
AutoScore was previously developed as an interpretable machine learning score generator, integrating both machine learning and point-based scores in the strong discriminability and accessibility. We have further extended it to the time-to-event outcomes and developed AutoScore-Survival, for generating time-to-event scores with right-censored survival data. Random survival forest provided an efficient solution for selecting variables, and Cox regression was used for score weighting. We implemented our proposed method as an R package. We illustrated our method in a study of 90-day survival prediction for patients in intensive care units and compared its performance with other survival models, the random survival forest, and two traditional clinical scores.
The AutoScore-Survival-derived scoring system was more parsimonious than survival models built using traditional variable selection methods (e.g., penalized likelihood approach and stepwise variable selection), and its performance was comparable to survival models using the same set of variables. Although AutoScore-Survival achieved a comparable integrated area under the curve of 0.782 (95% CI: 0.767-0.794), the integer-valued time-to-event scores generated are favorable in clinical applications because they are easier to compute and interpret.
Our proposed AutoScore-Survival provides a robust and easy-to-use machine learning-based clinical score generator to studies of time-to-event outcomes. It gives a systematic guideline to facilitate the future development of time-to-event scores for clinical applications.
评分系统具有高度可解释性,广泛用于评估医疗保健研究中的事件时间结局。然而,现有的事件时间评分主要是根据临床医生的知识,通过少数手动选择的变量临时创建的,这表明需要一种强大且高效的通用评分生成方法。
AutoScore 先前被开发为一种可解释的机器学习评分生成器,将机器学习和基于点的评分集成在一起,具有强大的可区分性和可访问性。我们进一步将其扩展到事件时间结局,并开发了 AutoScore-Survival,用于生成带有右删失生存数据的事件时间评分。随机生存森林为变量选择提供了一种有效的解决方案,Cox 回归用于评分加权。我们将我们的方法实现为一个 R 包。我们在一项 ICU 患者 90 天生存预测研究中说明了我们的方法,并将其性能与其他生存模型、随机生存森林和两个传统临床评分进行了比较。
AutoScore-Survival 衍生的评分系统比使用传统变量选择方法(例如,惩罚似然方法和逐步变量选择)构建的生存模型更为简约,其性能与使用相同变量集的生存模型相当。尽管 AutoScore-Survival 实现了可比较的综合曲线下面积 0.782(95%CI:0.767-0.794),但其生成的整数值事件时间评分在临床应用中是有利的,因为它们更容易计算和解释。
我们提出的 AutoScore-Survival 为事件时间结局研究提供了一种强大且易于使用的基于机器学习的临床评分生成器。它为未来开发临床应用的事件时间评分提供了系统的指导。