Usher Institute - University of Edinburgh, Old Medical School, Teviot Place, Edinburgh, EH8 9AG, UK.
Usher Institute - University of Edinburgh, Old Medical School, Teviot Place, Edinburgh, EH8 9AG, UK.
Public Health. 2022 Jan;202:49-51. doi: 10.1016/j.puhe.2021.10.011. Epub 2021 Dec 8.
Local authorities in Scotland are required to produce a Local Development Plan (LDP), which allocates sites for development and sets policies to guide decisions on planning applications. As part of this, local authorities must undertake a Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA). This is a structured assessment of likely environmental impacts, which includes human health. This study explores how SEA practitioners and SEA consultation authorities consider health.
Qualitative study design using eight in-depth semi-structured interviews.
Individual interviews were carried out with SEA practitioners from six local authority areas in Scotland and two SEA consultation authorities. Interviews were recorded, transcribed and analysed thematically.
Respondents articulated a broad perspective on health, but this was not reflected in SEA practice. Barriers to considering health more fully in SEA included low confidence in assessing health, limited partnership working with public health professionals and the lack of a consultation authority able to cover all aspects of health. Respondents valued partnership work between public health and planning professionals.
This study suggests recent work in Scotland to increase understanding of the role of spatial planning to influence health has been successful. However, further work is required to expand this to include links between spatial planning and health inequalities. SEA in Scotland does not currently support holistic consideration of health and health inequalities. Strong partnership working between public health and other sectors can increase understanding of links with health and create healthy places.
苏格兰地方当局必须制定地方发展计划(LDP),为发展分配场地,并制定政策来指导规划申请的决策。作为其中的一部分,地方当局必须进行战略环境评估(SEA)。这是对可能的环境影响进行的结构化评估,其中包括人类健康。本研究探讨了 SEA 从业者和 SEA 咨询当局如何考虑健康问题。
采用定性研究设计,使用 8 次深入的半结构化访谈。
对来自苏格兰六个地方当局和两个 SEA 咨询当局的 SEA 从业者进行了个人访谈。对访谈进行了录音、转录和主题分析。
受访者表达了对健康的广泛看法,但这并没有反映在 SEA 实践中。在 SEA 中更全面地考虑健康的障碍包括对评估健康的信心不足、与公共卫生专业人员的合作有限以及缺乏能够涵盖健康所有方面的咨询当局。受访者重视公共卫生和规划专业人员之间的合作。
本研究表明,苏格兰最近为提高对空间规划影响健康的作用的理解所做的工作取得了成功。然而,需要进一步努力将其扩大到包括空间规划与健康不平等之间的联系。苏格兰的 SEA 目前不支持全面考虑健康和健康不平等。公共卫生和其他部门之间的强有力的合作可以增进对与健康相关的联系的理解,并创造健康的场所。