Lillard Angeline S, Meyer M Joseph, Vasc Dermina, Fukuda Eren
Department of Psychology, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA, United States.
Front Psychol. 2021 Nov 25;12:721943. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.721943. eCollection 2021.
Wellbeing, or how people think and feel about their lives, predicts important life outcomes from happiness to health to longevity. Montessori pedagogy has features that enhance wellbeing contemporaneously and predictively, including self-determination, meaningful activities, and social stability. Here, 1905 adults, ages 18-81 ( = 36), filled out a large set of wellbeing scales followed by demographic information including type of school attended each year from 2 to 17. About half the sample had only attended conventional schools and the rest had attended Montessori for between 2 and 16 years ( = 8 years). To reduce the variable set, we first developed a measurement model of wellbeing using the survey data with exploratory then confirmatory factor analyses, arriving at four factors: general wellbeing, engagement, social trust, and self-confidence. A structural equation model that accounted for age, gender, race, childhood SES, and years in private school revealed that attending Montessori for at least two childhood years was associated with significantly higher adult wellbeing on all four factors. A second analysis found that the difference in wellbeing between Montessori and conventional schools existed even among the subsample that had exclusively attended private schools. A third analysis found that the more years one attended Montessori, the higher one's wellbeing as an adult. Unmeasured selection effects could explain the results, in which case research should determine what third variable associated with Montessori schooling causes adult wellbeing. Several other limitations to the study are also discussed. Although some of these limitations need to be addressed, coupled with other research, including studies in which children were randomly assigned to Montessori schools, this study suggests that attending Montessori as a child might plausibly cause higher adult wellbeing.
幸福安康,即人们对自己生活的看法和感受,预示着从幸福到健康再到长寿等重要的生活结果。蒙台梭利教育法具有一些能同时从当下和未来提升幸福安康的特点,包括自主决定、有意义的活动以及社会稳定。在此,1905名年龄在18至81岁(平均年龄 = 36岁)的成年人填写了大量幸福安康量表,随后提供了人口统计学信息,包括从2岁到17岁每年所就读学校的类型。大约一半的样本只上过传统学校,其余的人在蒙台梭利学校就读了2至16年(平均 = 8年)。为了减少变量集,我们首先使用调查数据通过探索性然后验证性因素分析来建立一个幸福安康的测量模型,得出四个因素:总体幸福安康、参与度、社会信任和自信。一个考虑了年龄、性别、种族、童年社会经济地位以及在私立学校就读年限的结构方程模型显示,童年至少在蒙台梭利学校就读两年与所有四个因素上显著更高的成人幸福安康相关。第二项分析发现,即使在只上过私立学校的子样本中,蒙台梭利学校和传统学校在幸福安康方面的差异也存在。第三项分析发现,一个人在蒙台梭利学校就读的年限越多,其成年后的幸福安康程度就越高。未测量的选择效应可能解释这些结果,在这种情况下,研究应该确定与蒙台梭利学校教育相关的第三个变量是什么导致了成人的幸福安康。还讨论了该研究的其他几个局限性。尽管其中一些局限性需要解决,但结合其他研究,包括儿童被随机分配到蒙台梭利学校的研究,这项研究表明童年就读于蒙台梭利学校可能合理地导致更高的成人幸福安康。