Clinical Research, Surrey Memorial Hospital, Fraser Health, Critical Care Tower T2-820, 13750 96th Avenue, Surrey, BC, V3V 1Z2, Canada.
Department of Evaluation and Research Services, Fraser Health, Surrey, BC, Canada.
BMC Geriatr. 2021 Dec 18;21(1):723. doi: 10.1186/s12877-021-02660-6.
A crucial aspect of continued senior care is the early detection and management of frailty. Developing reliable and secure electronic frailty assessment tools can benefit virtual appointments, a need especially relevant in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. An emerging effort has targeted web-based software applications to improve accessibility and usage. The objectives of this scoping review are to identify and evaluate web-based frailty assessment tools currently available and to identify challenges and opportunities for future development.
We conducted a review with literature (e.g., using MEDLINE databases) and Google searches (last updated on October 10, 2021). Each of the identified web applications were assessed based on eight featured categories and assigned a rating score accordingly.
Twelve web-based frailty assessment applications were found, chiefly provided by the USA (50%) or European countries (41%) and focused on frailty grading and outcome prediction for specific patient groups (59%). Categories that scored well among the applications included the User Interface (2.8/3) and the Cost (2.7/3). Other categories had a mean score of 1.6/3 or lower. The least developed feature was Data Saving.
Web-based applications represent a viable option for remote frailty assessments and multidisciplinary integrated care of older adults. Despite the available web-based frailty assessments on the Internet, many missed certain needed features for professional use in healthcare settings. This situation calls for fully comprehensive web-based applications, taking into consideration a number of key functions linking graphical user interface and functionalities, and paying special attention to secure data management.
持续的老年人护理的一个关键方面是早期发现和管理虚弱。开发可靠和安全的电子虚弱评估工具可以受益于虚拟预约,这在 COVID-19 大流行的背景下尤为重要。一项新的努力针对基于网络的软件应用程序,以提高可及性和使用率。本研究旨在确定和评估目前可用的基于网络的虚弱评估工具,并确定未来发展的挑战和机遇。
我们进行了文献综述(例如,使用 MEDLINE 数据库)和谷歌搜索(最后更新于 2021 年 10 月 10 日)。根据八个特色类别对每个确定的网络应用程序进行评估,并相应地分配评分。
发现了 12 种基于网络的虚弱评估应用程序,主要由美国(50%)或欧洲国家(41%)提供,主要针对特定患者群体的虚弱分级和预后预测(59%)。应用程序中得分较高的类别包括用户界面(2.8/3)和成本(2.7/3)。其他类别得分为 1.6/3 或更低。开发程度最低的功能是数据保存。
基于网络的应用程序是远程虚弱评估和老年人多学科综合护理的可行选择。尽管互联网上有可用的基于网络的虚弱评估,但许多评估都缺少在医疗保健环境中专业使用所需的某些功能。这种情况需要全面的基于网络的应用程序,考虑到将图形用户界面和功能联系起来的一些关键功能,并特别注意安全的数据管理。