Arida Ricardo Mario, Passos Adrielle Andrade, Graciani Alexandre Lebedev, Brogin João Angelo Ferres, Ribeiro Mayara de Almeida Lima, Faber Jean, Gutierre Robson Campos, Teixeira-Machado Lavinia
Department of Physiology, Federal University of São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil.
Department of Education in Health, Federal University of Sergipe, São Cristóvão, Brazil.
Front Neurol. 2021 Dec 10;12:771123. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2021.771123. eCollection 2021.
Clinical and pre-clinical studies indicate a reduction in seizure frequency as well as a decrease in susceptibility to subsequently evoked seizures after physical exercise programs. In contrast to the influence of exercise after epilepsy previously established, various studies have been conducted attempting to investigate whether physical activity reduces brain susceptibility to seizures or prevents epilepsy. We report a systematic review and meta-analysis of different animal models that addressed the impact of previous physical exercise programs to reduce seizure susceptibility. We included animal model (rats and mice) studies before brain insult that reported physical exercise programs compared with other interventions (sham, control, or naïve). We excluded studies that investigated animal models after brain insult, associated with supplement nutrition or drugs, that did not address epilepsy or seizure susceptibility, studies, studies, studies in humans, or studies. Electronic searches were performed in the MEDLINE (PubMed), Web of Science (WOS), Scopus, PsycINFO, Scientific Electronic Library Online (SciELO) databases, and gray literature, without restrictions to the year or language of publication. We used SYRCLE's risk of bias tool and CAMARADES checklist for study quality. We performed a synthesis of results for different types of exercise and susceptibility to seizures by random-effects meta-analysis. Fifteen studies were included in the final analysis (543 animals), 13 of them used male animals, and Wistar rats were the most commonly studied species used in the studies (355 animals). The chemoconvulsants used in the selected studies were pentylenetetrazol, penicillin, kainic acid, pilocarpine, and homocysteine. We assessed the impact of study design characteristics and the reporting of mitigations to reduce the risk of bias. We calculated a standardized mean difference effect size for each comparison and performed a random-effects meta-analysis. The meta-analysis included behavioral analysis (latency to seizure onset, = 6 and intensity of motor signals, = 3) and electrophysiological analysis (spikes/min, = 4, and amplitude, = 6). The overall effect size observed in physical exercise compared to controls for latency to seizure onset was -130.98 [95% CI: -203.47, -58.49] (seconds) and the intensity of motor signals was -0.40 [95% CI: -1.19, 0.40] (on a scale from 0 to 5). The largest effects were observed in electrophysiological analysis for spikes/min with -26.96 [95% CI: -39.56, -14.36], and for spike amplitude (μV) with -282.64 [95% CI: -466.81, -98.47]. . A higher number of animal models should be employed for analyzing the influence of exerciseon seizure susceptibility. The high heterogeneity in our meta-analysis is attributable to various factors, including the number of animals used in each study and the limited number of similar studies. . Studies selected in this systematic review and meta-analysis suggest that previous physical exercise programs can reduce some of the main features related to seizure susceptibility [latency seizure onset, spikes/min, and spike amplitude (μV)] induced by the administration of different chemoconvulsants. PROSPERO, identifier CRD42021251949; https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?RecordID=251949.
临床和临床前研究表明,体育锻炼计划实施后,癫痫发作频率降低,且对随后诱发的癫痫发作的易感性也降低。与先前确定的癫痫发作后运动的影响相反,已经进行了各种研究,试图调查体育活动是否会降低大脑对癫痫发作的易感性或预防癫痫。我们报告了一项系统综述和荟萃分析,该分析涉及不同动物模型,探讨了先前的体育锻炼计划对降低癫痫发作易感性的影响。我们纳入了脑损伤前的动物模型(大鼠和小鼠)研究,这些研究报告了体育锻炼计划,并与其他干预措施(假手术、对照或未处理)进行了比较。我们排除了那些研究脑损伤后动物模型的研究,这些研究与补充营养或药物有关,未涉及癫痫或癫痫发作易感性,以及人体研究。在MEDLINE(PubMed)、科学引文索引(Web of Science,WOS)、Scopus、PsycINFO、科学电子图书馆在线(Scientific Electronic Library Online,SciELO)数据库以及灰色文献中进行了电子检索,不受出版年份或语言的限制。我们使用SYRCLE的偏倚风险工具和CAMARADES清单来评估研究质量。我们通过随机效应荟萃分析对不同类型运动和癫痫发作易感性的结果进行了综合分析。最终分析纳入了15项研究(543只动物),其中13项研究使用雄性动物,Wistar大鼠是研究中最常用的物种(355只动物)。所选研究中使用的化学惊厥剂有戊四氮、青霉素、 kainic酸、毛果芸香碱和同型半胱氨酸。我们评估了研究设计特征的影响以及减少偏倚风险的缓解措施的报告情况。我们计算了每次比较的标准化平均差效应大小,并进行了随机效应荟萃分析。荟萃分析包括行为分析(癫痫发作开始潜伏期,n = 6,运动信号强度,n = 3)和电生理分析(每秒尖峰数,n = 4,幅度,n = 6)。与对照组相比,体育锻炼在癫痫发作开始潜伏期的总体效应大小为-130.98 [95%置信区间:-203.47,-58.49](秒),运动信号强度为-0.40 [95%置信区间:-1.19,0.40](范围为0至5)。在电生理分析中,每秒尖峰数的最大效应为-26.96 [95%置信区间:-39.56,-14.36],尖峰幅度(μV)的最大效应为-282.64 [95%置信区间:-466.81,-98.47]。 应采用更多的动物模型来分析运动对癫痫发作易感性的影响。我们荟萃分析中的高异质性归因于多种因素,包括每项研究中使用的动物数量以及类似研究数量有限。 本系统综述和荟萃分析中所选的研究表明,先前的体育锻炼计划可以减少与不同化学惊厥剂给药引起的癫痫发作易感性相关的一些主要特征[癫痫发作开始潜伏期、每秒尖峰数和尖峰幅度(μV)]。PROSPERO标识符:CRD42021251949;https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?RecordID=251949