Heerschop Samantha N, Biesbroek Sander, Boshuizen Hendriek C, Van't Veer Pieter
Division of Human Nutrition and Health, Wageningen University and Research, Wageningen, Netherlands.
Front Nutr. 2022 Jan 26;8:741286. doi: 10.3389/fnut.2021.741286. eCollection 2021.
Studies on sustainable diets show a need for replacement of animal-based foods by plant-based foods, which is also called "the protein transition." To gain insight into the acceptability of such diet shifts, this study evaluated which current food sources people consume at varying amounts of meat consumption. The study population consisted of 4,313 participants aged 1-79 years of the Dutch National Food Consumption Survey 2012-2016, which assessed diet using two nonconsecutive 24-h dietary recalls. A two-part statistical model was used that accounts for both repeated measures and the correlation between probability and amount of consumption. Results are presented for quartiles of low to high meat consumption, by age and sex. Depending on age and sex, a higher consumption of fish (>100%), nuts and seeds (73-156%), cheese (34-111%), and sweets and snacks (28-81%) is observed in the lowest quartile of meat consumption compared to the highest. For fish, nuts, seeds, and cheese, this increase is mainly due to probability of consumption (>100%, 61-93%, and 16-64%, respectively). For sweets and snacks, the increase is mainly due to the amount of consumption (26-72%). Probability of potato consumption is 29-51% lower at low meat consumption. Vegetable consumption is lower mainly due to amount of consumption (6-29%). The results from the two-part model suggest that shifting away from a traditional Dutch high meat-vegetable-potatoes pattern is associated with higher probability of consuming fish, nuts and seeds, and cheese, but also increased amounts of sweets and snacks. This illustrates that analyzing the probability and amount part separately in relation to behavioral or physiological determinants extends our understanding of the diet according to meat consumption. These insights are important when developing realistic and acceptable food-based dietary guidelines for meat reduction.
关于可持续饮食的研究表明,需要用植物性食物替代动物性食物,这也被称为“蛋白质转型”。为了深入了解这种饮食转变的可接受性,本研究评估了在不同肉类消费量的情况下,人们目前食用哪些食物来源。研究人群包括荷兰2012 - 2016年全国食物消费调查中的4313名年龄在1至79岁的参与者,该调查使用两次非连续的24小时饮食回忆法评估饮食情况。使用了一个两部分统计模型,该模型考虑了重复测量以及消费概率和消费量之间的相关性。结果按年龄和性别列出了从低到高肉类消费的四分位数情况。与最高肉类消费四分位数相比,在最低肉类消费四分位数中,根据年龄和性别,观察到鱼类(>100%)、坚果和籽类(73 - 156%)、奶酪(34 - 111%)以及甜食和零食(28 - 81%)的消费量更高。对于鱼类、坚果、籽类和奶酪,这种增加主要是由于消费概率(分别为>100%、61 - 93%和16 - 64%)。对于甜食和零食,增加主要是由于消费量(26 - 72%)。在低肉类消费时,土豆的消费概率低29 - 51%。蔬菜消费较低主要是由于消费量(6 - 29%)。两部分模型的结果表明,从传统的荷兰高肉类 - 蔬菜 - 土豆模式转变,与食用鱼类、坚果和籽类以及奶酪的更高概率相关,但也会增加甜食和零食的消费量。这说明分别分析与行为或生理决定因素相关的概率和数量部分,能够扩展我们对根据肉类消费情况的饮食的理解。在制定切实可行且可接受的减少肉类摄入的基于食物的饮食指南时,这些见解很重要。