Merenda Victoria R, de Oliveira Eduardo B, Fowler Heather N, Pairis-Garcia Monique D
Department of Population Health and Pathobiology, College of Veterinary Medicine, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC 27606, USA.
Department of Population Health and Reproduction, College of Veterinary Medicine, UC Davis, Tulare, CA 93274, USA.
Animals (Basel). 2022 Feb 9;12(4):409. doi: 10.3390/ani12040409.
The objective of this study was to explore perspectives and attitudes about euthanasia specific to the Brazilian dairy cattle industry. Twenty-five Brazilian citizens (13 veterinarians, 4 animal scientists, 3 professors, 3 researchers, 1 dairy owner, and 1 caretaker) participated in one of three focus groups conducted and recorded online (10, 8, and 7 participants per group). Questions regarding euthanasia were posed by a moderator, and the focus group discussions were then transcribed verbatim for analysis. After the initial data analysis, themes were evaluated and collapsed into three major categories: Euthanasia Training and Farm and Human Components. A complex interconnection between the three main themes and multiple subthemes specific to dairy cattle euthanasia was also revealed. The lack of nationally recognized euthanasia guidelines for dairy cattle paired with ineffective and inaccessible euthanasia tools makes it difficult for dairy veterinarians to implement humane protocols for on-farm euthanasia. In addition, logistical factors, particularly, the financial cost of euthanasia and the human-animal bond, play a role in the failure to perform euthanasia when warranted. Future studies should focus on the development of science-based standards and producer training to improve the consistency of on-farm euthanasia in Brazilian dairy operations.
本研究的目的是探讨巴西奶牛养殖业中关于安乐死的观点和态度。25名巴西公民(13名兽医、4名动物科学家、3名教授、3名研究人员、1名奶牛场主和1名饲养员)参与了在线进行并记录的三个焦点小组之一(每组分别有10名、8名和7名参与者)。一名主持人提出了关于安乐死的问题,然后对焦点小组讨论进行逐字记录以进行分析。在初步数据分析之后,对主题进行了评估并归纳为三大类:安乐死培训、农场因素和人员因素。还揭示了奶牛安乐死的三个主要主题与多个特定子主题之间的复杂相互联系。缺乏全国认可的奶牛安乐死指南,再加上无效且难以获取的安乐死工具,使得奶牛兽医难以实施人道的农场安乐死方案。此外,后勤因素,特别是安乐死的财务成本和人与动物的情感联系,在有必要时未能实施安乐死方面也起到了作用。未来的研究应侧重于制定基于科学的标准和对生产者进行培训,以提高巴西奶牛养殖作业中农场安乐死的一致性。